5 ms·
>The notion that bands should make music for the love of it was always romantic and now seems positively quaint. Rock groups are mini-corporations The top 0.1%
by tim333 8y ago
>The notion that bands should make music for the love of it was always romantic and now seems positively quaint. Rock groups are mini-corporations
The top 0.1% of rock groups maybe. The vast majority don't make significant money and probably do it mostly for the love of it and maybe a bit in the hope they'll make it one day.
- mothsonasloth 8y agoCompletely agree, profit is only one measure of success. Take a look at the progressive rock band Rush, they've been going since the late 60s. They still love what they do, and have evolved their styles over time. Even Iron Maiden who I would argue had commercial success and fame have survived a tumultuous time during the 90s and have come back even stronger.
- bb611 8y agoRush's last tour ended over three years ago and the band is over. Neil Peart has apparently left the music business entirely
- bpyne 8y agoMusicians have a history of taking long periods off. Sonny Rollins took a few multi-year stints off, during which time he worked on technique and ideas he didn't have time to work on as a touring musician. The Who have been in and out of retirement like 10 times. We'll see how long it lasts. He'll probably dedicate himself to writing for a few years and get himself back in shape with long-distance bicycling. But, he'll probably be back. I could easily see him not want to do arena tours anymore though, maybe some jazz gigs or small-venue acoustic sets with Rush. It's kind of interesting that two iconic drummers from the same generation - Bill Bruford and Neil Peart - decided to get out of the industry.
- BillSaysThis 8y agoGeddy Lee, in recent interviews for his new book, was pretty explicit about Peart being done with music and Rush being over.
- fooster 8y agoFor physical reasons.
- williamdclt 8y agoI don't entirely agree. If you want to have a chance to make it, you have to be more than just a group of guys playing music. You need to be professional, manage your booking, do networking, manage your music production...
- thegabriele 8y agoThat's right, but start by writing some good songs first (whatever the genre)...otherwise, business wise, it' probably better just to focus on being a tribute band.
- Kalium 8y agoIf I understand you correctly, you're advocating for creating an MVP before moving on to the questions of how to manage the business around it.
- thegabriele 8y agoOk: play something people want to hear.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- InitialLastName 8y agoSo what you're saying is, you need to have an idea of the market fit for your product.
- thegabriele 8y agoI'll go along: you're pitching your music and receiving feedbacks since the early stages of your startup band, so no need to study how to fit the market. Go fast, break strings.
- kemiller2002 8y ago
- dfxm12 8y agoThis is a poor attitude to assume about artists (I'd also challenge your assertions that 99.9% of people in rock groups "love" dealing with broken down vans, shady promoters, and trying to understand the nuance of record deals). They're putting in hard work just as anyone, and even if they love what they do, they're doing it to make a living. This type of thinking that devalues art and artists. Art is not a hobby, it's not a labor of love, it's a profession just like web development or project management.
- hennsen 8y agoNot every artist makes art to make a living if it, nor do they need to. Some can’t (e.g. because they don’t have and struggle to aquire the necessary business skills) and some don’t even want that... they just wanna make some art and are happy to do it just as a hobby, no business, no chores... There’s nothing wrong with that , it even has some upsides, because you really absolutely never need to do the slightest sacrifice in your works for economic or marketing reasons.