3 ms·
If LinkedIn has a 'delete profile' button that works, and extensions let recruiters scrape profiles and thus keep records on deleted users, who do you think is
by michaelt 8y ago
If LinkedIn has a 'delete profile' button that works, and extensions let recruiters scrape profiles and thus keep records on deleted users, who do you think is in the wrong?
- imhoguy 8y agoStill the recruiter can just "Save the page..."
- sangnoir 8y agoWho's in the wrong - the scraper, obviously. Why would you think LinkedIn would be on the hook - it's not like their "Delete Profile" button can wipe Google's/Internet Archives[1] cache. 1. I haven't read their robots.txt, but nothing I've read in GDPR remotely suggests "Right to be forgotten" features that attempt to erase data internet-wide.
- guitarbill 8y agoIf they have a "delete profile" button that works, then recruiters shouldn't be able to scrape that. It doesn't really matter, the country I live in has robust anti-spam and privacy laws. When I lived in the US, I was spammed often (CAN-SPAM is pretty weak compared to GDPR and CASL), but you don't see LinkedIn campaigning for better privacy laws in the US. Apart from campaigning for GDPR-style protections, there are enough other solutions. For example, GitHub has a nice email forwarding feature to preserve user's privacy/email address. LinkedIn could provide a similar option where when I opt-in, my email address is replaced by an address they provide. They could even go a step further and make it look like a real email address. Any emails to that address are forwarded to my real address, and after the initial forwarding I could reply from my real email address. Meanwhile LinkedIn could do analysis of who is sending what to these email canaries (like they transparently said they would when you opt in), and catch scrapers that way. For users, if I'm getting too much spam, I can simply request a new canary email address from them. This is what a user-focussed solution would look like. Not some weird semi-legal hack they are doing now.