3 ms·
Yes, and if smoking cured cancer then smoking would be an effective way of curing cancer. Problem is, you need to demonstrate that your claim is true, otherwis
by eesmith 8y ago
Yes, and if smoking cured cancer then smoking would be an effective way of curing cancer.
Problem is, you need to demonstrate that your claim is true, otherwise you're begging the question.
I agree that 1) if you widen the topic beyond the original claim, which was specifically about tobacco smoking, and 2) if you assume the correlation implies causation, then sure, you're right.
Except as I've now pointed out several times:
1) the comment you replied to was specifically about tobacco smoking, and trivially disproved if you (mistakenly) expand it to all types of smoking; and
2) neither the lead scientist quoted in the NPR piece nor the actual paper make the claim that smoking marijuana lowers parasite load, only that there is a correlation. Again, quoting the NPR piece, the lead scientist "doesn't know if the THC in the men's system is actually keeping the parasitic worms at bay".
Therefore, how do you know that smoking marijuana lowers parasite load? Please quote the relevant study.
Is this really the hill you want to die on?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]