2 ms·
More importantly, most people would prefer that the other drivers not disable those features in their arrogance. The false positive rate for things like automat
by wtallis 8y ago
More importantly, most people would prefer that the other drivers not disable those features in their arrogance. The false positive rate for things like automatic emergency braking is low enough that it definitely can't cause more harm than it prevents, and it really shouldn't be easy to turn off.
The same goes for the milder forms of lane keeping assist; that only gets problematic if the system does enough steering that the driver can get away with taking their hands off the wheel entirely when traveling on a typical interstate highway. The assist systems that give the wheel a minor nudge and audibly alert the driver are an obvious net safety gain, especially for the innocent bystanders in the next lane over.
Many of the more advanced safety features that are being rolled out to the market these days can be done wrong and become a danger of their own. But when implemented properly, complaints against them are no more valid than complaints about anti-lock brakes and electronic stability control overriding the driver's intentions.
- tropo 8y agoExample for braking: A car ahead of me in a lane to the right of me moves a bit left for the moment in order to give more space for a bicycle. My car brakes. I could get rear-ended. Example for lane following: I veer left a bit to avoid a bit of scrap wood with nails sticking out. The car counters this, steering me back toward the debris.
- wtallis 8y agoNobody is trying to say that driver assist systems will be perfect. But we're trying to get you to understand that perfect isn't the goal. The scenarios you outline are relatively far-fetched and their consequences are less severe than the crashes automatic emergency braking and lane keeping assistance are designed to prevent. Simply constructing a hypothetical situation in which these technologies might be less than perfect does nothing to support your position that they are not a net improvement to safety.