5 ms·
Even though I had a very good understanding of the anatomy of the eye and largely how vision works, my internal concept of vision was still kind of like what is
by jcims 8y ago
Even though I had a very good understanding of the anatomy of the eye and largely how vision works, my internal concept of vision was still kind of like what is described in the title.
Then I realized your retinas are more like a specialized tongue covered with lightbuds, and my sense of vision changed dramatically. I suddenly had a sense of blindness, that I could see only as far as the tips of the rods and cones in my eye, and everything beyond that was just lining up the photons so they made sense when they arrived.
- Arn_Thor 8y agoI so wish I hadn't read this.. My eyeballs are itching
- maxander 8y agoI think it's really interesting how when we learn new things (such as this lesson about how the eye works) we often only learn them "halfway." E.g., obviously, you're not blind, and you see as far as you like- but your old sense of how sight works involved contact, and your new concept didn't fully rid you of the notion that contact was a limiting factor. Only because these two contradictory notions could coexist in your mind did you feel "blind." Similarly, I've had people tell me that reading about the "microbiome" is really distressing, since afterwards they feel like they have some alien infestation in their bodies- as though they were full of bugs. On one level they learned a new thing, that healthy human bodies contain lots of various microorganisms, but some part of their psyche still maintained that any such creatures must be pathological. Their obvious health doesn't make them feel like microbiome theory is false, and nor does it fully convince them that their microbiome is benign. There's probably a lot of more subtle examples of this, and it probably goes a long way to explain why so many people find science to be distressing or depressing.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> I've had people tell me that reading about the "microbiome" is really distressing, since afterwards they feel like they have some alien infestation in their bodies- as though they were full of bugs. On one level they learned a new thing, that healthy human bodies contain lots of various microorganisms, but some part of their psyche still maintained that any such creatures must be pathological. We also all maintain the perception of "wholeness" of our body. But at the level of microbiome, it's just bunch of cells mixing with another bunch of cells, with different DNA. It's all one large bag of smart sand. It's another realization that may be hard for some people to handle.
- groestl 8y agoYes, I think that's exactly what I meant in my sibling comment!
- vanderZwan 8y ago> But at the level of microbiome, it's just bunch of cells mixing with another bunch of cells, with different DNA. It's all one large bag of smart sand. Well, in terms of biomass not quite, and our gut flora are also topologically still outside of our bodies. But I agree with the overall sentiment, whether we call it a bag of smart sand or a portable sealed-off climate controlled micro-ecology is just details.
- groestl 8y agoInteresting, my model of a pathogen (mostly shaped by my biology teacher), was one of a symbiont not completely adapted to the host body (yet). This was decades ago, but when I later read up on the microbiome, the image of an alien infestation did not really cross my mind. What caused me more concern was the (halfway) realization that this symbiosis goes as far a actually forming the human body.
- raattgift 8y ago> full of bugs Better not tell them about Demodex spp. Can you see your eyelash mites? http://www.optometrytimes.com/dry-eye/demodex-may-be-beneficial-humans http://www.optometrytimes.com/dry-eye/demodex-may-be-benefic...
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI think what you did is rolled back a layer of abstraction your brain created for you. Sure, your eyeballs are high-sampling-frequency tongues swimming in a sea of light. But the brain processes those raw sensory readings, fuses them with a bunch of other things, and presents it as a view of the world, and then to simplify things, it tells itself that this is the world. I'm actually super-interested in ways of building those layers of abstractions. Consider tool use. If you've used any tool a lot, you know the feeling of it becoming an extension of yourself. Proficient drivers don't think about moving the keyboard or turning the wheels, they just sort of are the car and will themselves to move where they want to go. As I type this comment, I don't think about my fingers pounding on the keyboard, I just will the words to appear on screen. The brain is good at papering over the mechanics of interacting with the world, and I think it's entirely feasible to start incorporating new senses if our devices can be designed around this purpose, instead of relying on explicitly displaying data for our eyes.
- 0x8BADF00D 8y agoIn other words, your data is only as good as your sensors.
- jfries 8y agoThis is very interesting. I remember reading about pilots placing an electrode on the tongue and eventually learning to intuitively feel what the external sensor was telling them. Or another one about a person wearing a belt which always vibrated in the spot facing north. This helped them navigate cities more efficiently after getting accustomed to the vibrations. Do you have other examples?
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThose were the exact two I have on my mind. I've actually started building an ankle bracelet for the north-sense to test it out on myself. People also reported getting a feel for strong EM fields in their surroundings after implanting a small magnet in a finger.
- 8y ago
- Erlich_Bachman 8y agoClassic example of using logical mind to become less effective as a human being: to bring the intellect into an area which already works well subconsciously and try to do it's job for it using thinking. :) The solution is to just trust your eyes and vision (and by extension, trust the universe at large, if you extend this into the spiritual realm): whatever the exact mechanism of the eyes is, they obviously work well for you. It doesn't make sense to take one small aspect of it (low number of lightbuds) and read too much into it, when its shortcomings are easily abstracted away by for example innate intelligence that scans the environment using those few bulbs, to produce a high-megapixel internal representation which will work well enough! Look at the big picture.