4 ms·
What is referred to as a "water transistor" in the article is in fact a standard industrial part, known as a hydraulic relay: https://www.bermad.com.au/categor
by userbinator 8y ago
What is referred to as a "water transistor" in the article is in fact a standard industrial part, known as a hydraulic relay:
https://www.bermad.com.au/category/hydraulic-relays/ https://www.bermad.com.au/category/hydraulic-relays/
Instead of the BJT that is shown in the article, these act more like MOSFETs; and in fact, the "water analogy of electricity" translates quite well, since the "gate" has no current flow besides the tiny amount of "leakage" past the seals, and the volume of the actuating chamber and its return spring acts like the gate capacitance.
This is just to clear the OUT hose, so it will be ready for the next cycle. If this wasn't done, the WT could block in the "Logical One" in some circumstances.
...and that corresponds to the "high-Z" state, which along with the "capacitance" of the circuit would actually be usefully analogous to dynamic CMOS.
One more remark from someone who has worked with hydraulics before: the valve drawn in the diagram is known as a spool valve, and usually for diverting the flow of fluid, the chambers would be so arranged that they don't create any forces on the valve spool --- see how pressure on the "VCC" or "GND" ports would act on the land and tend to push the valve? In practice a "balanced spool" design is used, where the pressure of the controlled fluid is balanced on both ends:
http://www.modernhydraulics.net/images/hydes/uploads/2011/01/flow-condition.jpg http://www.modernhydraulics.net/images/hydes/uploads/2011/01...
- agumonkey 8y agoI wonder if one day we'll ~program other than linear topologies. Something more like chemical reactions in 3D. Or maybe that would lead to biology.
- kurthr 8y agoRemember that the complexity of programming is built on the simplicity (structured, independent, repeatable actions) of the processor/language/OS. Mechanical (esp 3D) and Chemical systems are so complex that modeling the results of highly simplified systems is often almost impossible, results are nonlinear and mixed with "unrelated" inputs and prior state, and thus results are "chaotic" and unpredictable. That's not usually what you want to base a complex system on. Now if you can simplify operations like DNA... you may have a chance, but it's still quite difficult.
- agumonkey 8y agoUnderstood, but complexity ~just needs a proper abstraction (see quantum mechanics) to make it reasonable.
- kurthr 8y agoI'd like to agree, but when I look at quantum computers all the problems are in scalability, error correction, temporal stability... etc. Those have to do with many of the same problems that plague mechanical and chemical systems: non-local coupling, non-linear mixing, inherent thermal noise.
- agumonkey 8y agoYou know more than I do it seems, I might be naive. Although, transistors were feeble at first.. who knows.
- kurthr 8y agoThe beautiful thing about electronics (and hydrolics) is their inherent 1 dimensionality (although you can create higher dimensional interconnections). Electrical components in particular can be spectacularly linear (capacitors and log-lin diodes) over 4-8 orders of magnitude. The great thing about transistors is their localized non-liniarity (gain)... which was used to create simplified digital systems from analog circuits. This allowed fan-out and noise tolerance... which allowed more complex abstractions, processors and OSes to be built on top them.
- agumonkey 8y agoI guess even if we try chemo-spatial things.. we'll end up reusing linear network topology knowledge. But then.. I see radial wave local interactions and diffusion laws.. Just a thought.