5 ms·
Interesting. What if they use a subreddit as their forum and then let Reddit do the censoring for them? Would Reddit in this case be obliged to keep all posts
by mc32 8y ago
Interesting. What if they use a subreddit as their forum and then let Reddit do the censoring for them? Would Reddit in this case be obliged to keep all posts there whether they violate their TOS or not? Looks like you're saying they cannot since the TOS would lead Reddit to violate constitutional rights of users.
- tptacek 8y agoI mean we're way off into the weeds here of what I think even a lawyer who specialized in this stuff could tell you for sure and I'm not a lawyer of any sort but... ... I think that if this ruling creates a longstanding binding precedent, that precedent will be that government officials are responsible for the totality of moderation that occurs on the platforms they select to use for things that have sufficient nexus to their official duties. So if Reddit censored people in ways that would violate the constitution were a state-run Reddit.gov to do them, that might create standing to sue (the official, not Reddit). So there's probably some creative legal trolling to be done here by white supremacists or whatever? I would be surprised if they won though? Like: you can be banned for life from a shopping mall for walking around with a flaming cross duct-taped to a visor or whatever (is that what the kids do now?) and I doubt that means the mayor will get sued for having a town hall in that mall. Sometimes I just write words in a long sequence randomly enough in the hopes that Rayiner or Daniel Berlin will smack me down. Sometimes it works, so maybe we'll get a more credible answer.
- MRD85 8y agoAt what point does the behaviour that can ban you from a place be defined? An official can't open their office in an area restricted to a protected class so there is a defined line somewhere in between banning flaming crosses and banning protected classes. My issue with this is that it gives a human the ability to define non-acceptable non-criminal behaviour.
- mc32 8y agoRight. What if it's held at a free to enter location which has a $10 parking fee (county fairgrounds or whatnot). I guess this might be one of those wishy-washy "We'll know it when we see it" things which can take a tortuous route depending on the details, appeals, etc.
- tptacek 8y agoI don't understand. We all define non-acceptable non-criminal behavior all the time.
- bilbo0s 8y agoThat's not how it works. Never has been. If you are a politician, you are perfectly free to speak at the local Klan rally. (David Duke does it all the time.) The fact that blacks are not allowed at the Klan rally is a problem for blacks, but not for David Duke. He is free, and I would think even encouraged, to engage with as many constituents as possible. Wherever he can find them. So for instance, if David Duke had a noblacksallowed.com page, BUT he also had an office in a non-restricted area, he's good. You or I may not like that, but there is no Constitutional restriction against what he's doing. Blacks are perfectly free to go to his office for the purposes of making comments or lodging complaints. Being black is completely non-criminal, but, unfortunately, there exists a group of people for whom being black is also completely non-acceptable. And that group of people are absolutely free to set up exclusionary areas on their own private property. David Duke may even happen to speak in some of those exclusionary areas. Again, you or I may not like that fact, but that's just reality. Nothing's really changed with this ruling, it always has been like this.
- MRD85 8y agoWhat if the town hall is in a nonblacksallowed site? If you're banned from a shopping mall that has the only town hall it is going to have the same affect on your life.
- bilbo0s 8y agoThe noblacksallowed mall is allowed to have meetings on their private property at their sole discretion. (I'm assuming that the noblacsallowed mall is a private mall with a racial exclusivity clause in its membership requirements.) So at the meetings they are also free to invite and host, as a guest speaker, whatever politician they choose. There's no Constitutional power that the government would have to stop that. So again, the David Dukes of the world are safe. David Duke is free to do any guest appearance for his constituents or anyone else at any venue they want. We may not like that, but that's just how it's always worked. Now there might be an issue if David Duke were to put his official full time office in the noblacksallowed mall, and conduct ALL his official business there. But even then, that would be an issue for David Duke, NOT an issue for the mall.
- andrewflnr 8y ago> Reddit.gov This string... Hilarious, scary, absurd, or all the above, it's a remarkable string, considered both in and out of context.