3 ms·
That's what it was like in 2016. I remember seeing the headline for the DAO hack on HN back then and thinking "Wow, good thing I didn't invest in this Ethereum
by nostrademons 8y ago
That's what it was like in 2016. I remember seeing the headline for the DAO hack on HN back then and thinking "Wow, good thing I didn't invest in this Ethereum thing". Someone had told me about it in 2015, I took a quick glance and passed thinking "Looks like a scam." Then 2017 happened and the joke was on me. Then 2018 happened and the joke was on them again.
New technologies are always shitshows when they get started. I remember DoubleClick ads hanging every copy of Netscape they ran on, ActiveX controls that could pwn your computer just by viewing a webpage, and unusable college Internet because the SQL Slammer worm had infected 50% of computers on campus and would reinfect anything as soon as it was plugged back in. The last was in 2003, 14 years after the Internet was introduced - put on the Bitcoin timeline, that's 4 years in the future, assuming cryptocurrency is adopted as fast as the Internet (and there're good reasons to believe it won't be).
The thing about disruptive technologies is that people continue to use them despite how shitty the technology is - they're so desperate for a solution that they put up with a solution that basically doesn't work.
- aidenn0 8y agoI had the XP service pack burned to a CD (or maybe DVD?) because on my college campus Code Red would infect a computer on install faster than you could download the patches.
- nickpsecurity 8y ago"New technologies are always shitshows when they get started. " A key difference is most of the new techs like Internet, email, Paypal, and so on improved on what people already had in a way that delivered obvious value. They also came with problems. Whereas, nobody I know in real life wants the drawbacks of these cryptocurrencies that come with giving up the benefits of their current, centralized offerings. The only folks I know out here doing crypto are speculators (esp day traders). That's the difference. Now, if they wanted to solve those problems, they'd start with whatever tech/law/orgs already worked, identify their problems, and then mitigate them using proven methods. So, we're looking at credit unions, non-profits, or public-benefit companies chartered to make sure they do specific good things and don't do specific bad things. The most important stuff at least. These can be in the licenses and contracts, too, for re-enforcement. Then, centralized systems with decentralized checking of what's exchanged a la SWIFT all using existing high-performance tech we know how to secure. Open protocols and agreements for how disputes will be resolved in situations using decentralized mode with experts from both centralized and decentralized models weighing in on that. I've been talking about that in Gerard's threads on Lobsters: https://lobste.rs/s/wxqkyj/bitcoin_s_stupendous_power_waste_is_green#c_mygfqo https://lobste.rs/s/wxqkyj/bitcoin_s_stupendous_power_waste_... https://lobste.rs/s/opge2r/electricity_consumed_by_bitcoin#c_cds5tt https://lobste.rs/s/opge2r/electricity_consumed_by_bitcoin#c... I can't find the other ones sense the search feature is limited. "they're so desperate for a solution that they put up with a solution that basically doesn't work. " That's true when there's a need. This is part of a hype cycle pushing stuff people don't need to replace stuff that would meet their needs fine. Accelerated by massive amounts of money being thrown all over this area. Totally different kind of thing. The stuff that bubbles, bankruptcies, and broken dreams are made of.
- lojack 8y ago> A key difference is most of the new techs like Internet, email, Paypal, and so on improved on what people already had in a way that delivered obvious value. I'd argue that for most people the value was only obvious afterwards. To put email in perspective, early adopters had to choose between what they already knew and all the hurdles involved in connecting to the internet and using the new technology. There was also a good chance the people they were trying to communicate with didn't even have email. Outside of a few niche areas, email provided no obvious value to the vast majority of people for decades.
- nickpsecurity 8y agoThe thing I was getting at is, if you had a computer and Internet, then email would be a free, fast alternative to traditional mail. That has obvious benefit. Whereas, these currencies are volatile, slower, often dont allow charge backs, use more energy, and accepted at fewer places. Worse in every way to checking accounts and credit cards. Esp if we have multiple cards or accounts to reduce risk of single institution.
- lojack 8y ago> if you had a computer and Internet Thats a lot of hand waving for something that wasn't trivial at all in the 60s and 70s.
- tuesdayrain 8y agoNo chargebacks is a feature in many situations.
- stickfigure 8y agoWorse in every way to checking accounts and credit cards. Quite a few Venezuelans would beg to differ about that.
- oblio 8y agoSo for cryptocurrencies to be the "better solution" you just need your entire country to have a total meltdown lasting multiple years?
- acdha 8y ago> The last was in 2003, 14 years after the Internet was introduced - put on the Bitcoin timeline, that's 4 years in the future, assuming cryptocurrency is adopted as fast as the Internet This is a common comparison but it’s based on a very dubious equation of the history. By 2003, the internet had transformed many industries — e-commerce was in the billions of dollar range (Amazon’s earliest business lines had been profitable for the better part of a decade by then); millions of people used it daily for tasks like research or customer service, software or media downloads, etc. Mainstream media and ads were full of URLs not just for internet companies but for existing companies which were increasingly focused on the internet. In contrast, Bitcoin has almost no reason for anyone to care about it other than speculation and the few people who do use it regularly for anything else are largely using it as a replacement for PayPal with worse customer protections.
- profalseidol 8y agoEthereum (the one where "The DAO" hack happened) is project that initially released in July 2015 [1]. The Roadmap was provided in the beginning and it is clearly understood that it is a work in progress. It is not yet ready for general public use. Bitcoin is an entirely different project. Although it is also a blockchain, it's like a calculator while the former is a fully programmable computer. These two projects are very different, two different groups of developers. I encourage you read into them more to educate yourself. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum
- ric2b 8y ago> Someone had told me about it in 2015, I took a quick glance and passed thinking "Looks like a scam." Then 2017 happened and the joke was on me. Then 2018 happened and the joke was on them again. Pretty sure the joke is still on you when comparing to someone that told you about it in 2015. The highest price for ETH in 2015 was $2.19, lowest in 2018 was $85. So even with the worst possible entry/exit in those years we're still talking about a 3881% ROI in 3 years. Again, that's the WORST possible ROI for entering in 2015 and leaving in 2018.