7 ms·
The only condition where I'd see this being true is if VR leads to "good as there" telepresence, where you can feel like you're having the sort of spontaneous c
by nostrademons 8y ago
The only condition where I'd see this being true is if VR leads to "good as there" telepresence, where you can feel like you're having the sort of spontaneous conversations that arise from physical presence at a workplace.
Telepresence done right would be an absolutely huge economic boon - it subsumes transportation, housing, national boundaries, and lots of education and training. If you could get the same sort of "all the web experts in the room" like you get in Silicon Valley or "all the electronics experts in the room" like you get in Shenzhen, but do so where you literally have all the experts (rather than just those who live in those cities), you'd get rid of a lot of economic inefficiencies like houses costing 40x more in Silicon Valley than Detroit.
Failing that, I see it as a niche product that'd revolutionize the entertainment industries but doesn't change much outside of them.
- mrguyorama 8y agoI love using VR, even for long (3 or more hours straight, no breaks) periods, but dear lord would I hate using a VR headset to pretend I'm in an office. Open offices are trash in the first place (at least for me), headsets do not have enough resolution to pretend to have a screen in front of me, and even if they did, it would likely produce more eyestrain than just looking at an actual HD screen in front of you.
- sl1ck731 8y agoMaybe wearing it all day as an office is a little overkill. But being able to collaborate even in front of some kind of 3D whiteboard room would be a killer for fully remote teams like mine. Drawing on paint-like sites or with clunky web apps has been one of my biggest pains that VR controllers, if done right, could be huge for me. Maybe with enough presence remote would become even more commonplace. A man can dream.
- radiorental 8y agoTwo thoughts, based on evaluating remote collaboration tech. 1) Writing on virtual whiteboard in VR just doesn't feel right, there's no tactile feedback. It's doable but doesn't beat a real whiteboard (nothing beats a real whiteboard) 2) Observe people working at a whiteboard. It's predominantly an asynchronous one to many form of communication. Multiple people writing on the same board at the same time isn't how we communicate with each other. The best in class tool I've found to date is Microsoft's Whiteboard app running on their 84" Surface Hub. Anyone who has the budget I highly recommend taking a look at it. The app itself is free on windows 10.
- umeshunni 8y ago> 1) Writing on virtual whiteboard in VR just doesn't feel right, there's no tactile feedback. To be fair, people said that in 2007 about virtual keyboards.
- radiorental 8y agoAre you talking about the iPhone?? That's not a virtual keyboard. Your finger knows when it's touching the screen. Also, tapping on designate target and freeform drawing are two very different things There's no possible such affordance in virtual space. You're literally writing in air.
- rock_hard 8y agoI think what she/he meant is that “doesn’t feel” right is a moving target
- rhacker 8y agoGuessing he was referring to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projection_keyboard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projection_keyboard
- coldtea 8y ago>Are you talking about the iPhone?? That's not a virtual keyboard. Your finger knows when it's touching the screen But it doesn't feel that it's hitting a button (because the button it's virtual), and people then had made this point repeatedly (e.g. in favor of Blackberry).
- qu4z-2 8y agoI would've made that argument then, and it's the reason I have a Blackberry today. It's just straight up not as good, in my opinion. But yes, people in general seem to be fine with it. I just wanted to push back against the idea that "Well, everyone said it would be bad and then it was fine.". The people who thought it was awful in many cases probably still do, they're just quieter about it 'cause it's a lost cause.
- diminoten 8y agoI'm a remote employee and I would love the ability to "step into" a meeting.
- Balgair 8y agoJane is clever, thought Greg, more clever than Jose, but not that clever. BigCorp had introduced the VR goggles about eight months ago, and though it was initially a boon, most of the dev team had come to hate them. Sure, working at home was nice at first. You didn't have to wear pants anymore, you could cook fish in you apartment and not get death-stares, the commute over the Bay Bridge was gone along with the tolls. But it quickly became apparent that you still had to 'put ass to seat.' Initially you could skip out, take a long lunch, go to the dentist, take the dog out when you were bored stiff from the monotony. But then that first update came out. Thing was, in order to downplay the nausea effects from the screens, the goggles tracked your eyes' saccades, pupil dilation, and a bunch of other bioengineering stuff Greg barely knew about. It really did help with the nausea, not the Greg really suffered from it to begin with. His ex-girlfriend certainly did, making VR-sexting nearly impossible with her back in NYC. It wasn't so much that the VR-goggles could track exactly what you were looking at, that data stream was just too much to parse, it was that they knew you were there at all. Once most of the dev team was no longer in the bullpen, and instead they were off actually living a life, productivity skyrocketed. Well, initially. Greg's boss, Jose, had loved it. But as the product reached it's natural limits, sigmoided to the economy, the squeeze began. At first, the number of tickets became the metric to game. Then it was peer-feedback, which naturally came to an armistice between all of them. One thing after another, as Jose was squeezed from all of this many bosses. Until eventually, you had to have 'continuous telepresence' during work hours. Sure, when the new JK Rowling product came out, the entire virtual office became Hogwartz, complete with the ghosts and staircases. Fridays were a reliable beach scene. Mondays had that dark humor of a Dilbert strip in the skin and layout of the office. But Jose had each scene constructed so that he could monitor if you were there. Like a manager in a Cuban Cigar factory, his seat was higher. He could easily see if you were there in his goggles. A little red mark in Jose's HUD came up when you pulled out of the office. He had to, it was one of the few metrics he knew about and that he could manipulate to appease the matrix of his bosses. 'Put ass to seat'. But Jane knew people. Greg didn't know who she knew, maybe one of the hardware guys at the VR goggle plant. But Jane was faking it. Greg has seen it, cataloged it, and studied it. The times she would message him, idly talking about some show, all of them were pulled from the NYT's RSS, easily a chatbot she'd actually paid for. The voice was just that side of choppy. And the way her head moved, that here eyes scanned across Greg's virtual face, totally scripted. He'd seen her replay the exact facial scan at least six times in one meeting. Greg knew: Jane was faking it.
- albemuth 8y agoOut of curiosity, what do you use VR for? Haven't found an application yet to make me finally buy a headset.
- mrguyorama 8y agoHot dogs, horseshoes, and hand grenades (essentially a shooting range simulator with almost 300 accurately modeled firearms and plenty of game modes with more content added pretty much weekly) Beat Saber is a VR rhythm game, and I adore rhythm games Multiple driving/racing sims, including assetto corsa, project cars, and Euro Truck simulator (though I struggle to play that one in VR) VTOL VR is an incredible near future Flight and military simulation seemingly focusing on weapons handling I have over 30 VR applications, and at least 10 I would consider full fledged "games", but those are what I spend most of my time in
- 8note 8y agoI feel like there's a definitional problem with that for vr: you're still wearing the big black glasses/head gear, so if you can see everyone naturally, you can't actually see their faces
- masklinn 8y agoAlso VR won't magically break through the speed of light, getting realistic telepresence with lag is going to be… interesting.
- fooker 8y agoThat is going to be the least of the issues. Even with a 100ms lag, conversation s still feel real time.
- technotony 8y agoTry out high fidelity VR... they've nailed it already: https://highfidelity.com https://highfidelity.com
- nostrademons 8y agoThe software would presumably know what you look like and can record your facial expressions and map it onto your avatar in real-time. There's technology now to create faces that never existed on a real person, and there's been technology for 15 years or so to do motion-capture of facial expressions and map it onto a computer-generated texture. Plus I would hope that the big black glasses eventually give way to something sleeker, more akin to an eyepatch or sleeping mask.
- greeneggs 8y agoFor example, HIGH-FIDELITY FACIAL AND SPEECH ANIMATION FOR VR HMDS Kyle Olszewski, Joseph J. Lim, Shunsuke Saito, Hao Li Siggraph Asia 2016 http://www.hao-li.com/publications/papers/siggraphAsia2016HFFSAVH.pdf http://www.hao-li.com/publications/papers/siggraphAsia2016HF... FACIAL PERFORMANCE SENSING HEAD-MOUNTED DISPLAY Hao Li, Laura Trutoiu, Kyle Olszewski, Lingyu Wei, Tristan Trutna, Pei-Lun Hsieh, Aaron Nicholls, Chongyang Ma Siggraph 2015 http://www.hao-li.com/publications/papers/siggraph2015FPSHMD.pdf http://www.hao-li.com/publications/papers/siggraph2015FPSHMD...
- radiorental 8y agoWhat real-world use case does putting all the [insert job function] in a single virtual room solve? This is a case of tech looking for a solution. I pick up the phone or email people in the same building. I'm not sure jumping into a virtual room with people in different physical locations is a need. I love my VR headset for gaming, I have a really hard time seeing it implemented in our workplace: software company with development offices in US/UK/India. Being able to see each other's face is not how a lot of work is done imho. Collaborating using tools like MS Whiteboard on a surface hub to express and ideate on a design is where work gets done in my experience.
- ninth_ant 8y agoBusiness travel by airplane is extremely common. The fluidity of face-to-face communication aids cooperative work in a way that hasn’t yet been duplicated at scale, despite many efforts to date. That’s part of what VR aims to disrupt and achieve.
- radiorental 8y agoYes, but who are these people and what are they doing when they travel? VR is just a video conference call on steroids. Business travel is 'common' but relative to the rest of productive output at an average business it's peanuts. Also what portion of those business travelers absolutely need to be there. Would you buy from (a) a salesperson who took the time to travel to your workplace or (b) some telepresence pitch?
- vilhelmmoberg 8y agoIt's not peanuts to the environment. How about option c) donate the plane ticket to buy carbon offsets so as not to act "cheap". Even better, give the client that choice and see if they readily choose to pollute the environment (twice).
- jon-wood 8y agoMaybe I'm an outlier but I've had more productive video conferences with salespeople than I have with ones who've flown out to talk. Sure, you don't get the free steak lunch on a video call, but you also don't have to spend that lunch break being pitched on how amazingly cool their company is.
- matte_black 8y agoI doubt it. If this was true, we'd already be there. We have teleconferencing and long distance communications already, and this doesn't really happen. You would have to go beyond mere conferencing, and create specialized tools that can be interacted with in VR so people can produce something together that they couldn't before. There is little value in just having everyone pretend they're in an office.
- vilhelmmoberg 8y agoTry something like Rec Room on the Vive or Oculus before you proclaim it no different than video conferencing. This is a human perception problem and the feeling of being there and hand signals alone makes an enormous difference. You have to try it to understand. There are all these big and small factors for why video conferencing doesn't replace all communication. VR can in the long term remove most if not all of them, except for latency.
- rjvs 8y agoVery much agree; this is what we're doing at http://stirlinglabs.com http://stirlinglabs.com for large-scale engineering.
- dragontamer 8y agoVR Chat is one of the "killer apps" of VR. That and Beat Saber, I guess. I think a "serious" telepresence application would be good. VR Chat is a meme-haven / non-serious location for now. But... there's that good YCombinator blogpost about non-serious apps: https://blog.ycombinator.com/why-toys/ https://blog.ycombinator.com/why-toys/ It really does seem like VR Chat (as immature and silly as it is...) is a killer app. How to grow it into a serious application is still a major mystery to me, but I'd bet on VR Chat (or at least its successor that fixes its issues) to be a driving use of VR.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoMight be a PADS (Post-Anime Depression Syndrome), but after rewatching Sword Art Online recently, I found myself thinking that a VR Chat is actually a good idea, and something I would very much enjoy. With an ability to easily enough create and modify stuff in the virtual world (preferably mostly from within world, and I mean creating and modifying interactive objects, and absolutely no "buy funny clothes for your avatar in the platform's store" bullshit), I could imagine running a collaborative ideation space in it; a kind of half-baked virtual hackerspace. (I find this dream doubly alluring now that I found myself remote-working from a smaller town.)
- dragontamer 8y agoI mean, what you've described is basically Second Life (except inside of a VR headset). So yeah, I could see it working out well. 3d collaborative virtual worlds are a great toy and seem to build communities relatively easily. Its not really mainstream, but Second Life is still relatively big... and has a long-term presence. It was initially released in 2003. It is kinda surprising that people still play that game. 16 years is an eternity in the video game world. Also: > after rewatching Sword Art Online recently, I found myself thinking that a VR Chat is actually a good idea I'm pretty sure Sword Art Online was about how VR could be a... bad idea. Just saying. :-) Granted, I don't think we have any microwave death-triggers implemented on the back of real-world VR Headsets yet, so maybe we're safe from that particular problem.
- 8y ago
- scabarott 8y ago>Failing that, I see it as a niche product that'd revolutionize the entertainment industries but doesn't change much outside of them. Entertainment is certainly not niche by any definition. If VR replaces gaming consoles alone we're talking several Billion dollars. Let alone TV, Movie theaters, internet porn etc
- aurailious 8y ago> you'd get rid of a lot of economic inefficiencies like houses costing 40x more in Silicon Valley than Detroit. There are many more reasons for the housing cost disparity then closeness in work spaces.
- coldtea 8y ago>The only condition where I'd see this being true is if VR leads to "good as there" telepresence, where you can feel like you're having the sort of spontaneous conversations that arise from physical presence at a workplace. "All the tedium and productivity-killing of corporate meetings now in your telecommuting job" (tm)
- rjvs 8y agoIt doesn't have to be "as good as there" to be significantly useful, especially if you're not there just to talk.