6 ms·
There is nothing which will make you happy. You must choose to be happy. There is no job, no amount of money, no relationship, which will make you feel whole a
by vorpalhex 8y ago
There is nothing which will make you happy. You must choose to be happy.
There is no job, no amount of money, no relationship, which will make you feel whole and happy and content and done. The opposite doesn't hold - there are jobs and relationships and financial strains which will certainly keep you from being happy.
The goal isn't for a job or a relationship to make you happy. It's to enable other things which are your goals, which may or may not be happiness related.
- everdev 8y agoHappiness is an emotion, it comes and goes. Even the premise of "are you happy?" is missing the point. Are we talking about feeling happiness twice as much as feeling sadness? 4x, 10x? Sadness can come from things outside our control. I think a better goal is are you present? Are you listening to yourself and to what you really want for your life? Everyone will want different things but making an emotion the goal is a fools errand.
- elcomet 8y agoI don't believe happiness is an emotion. Joy is an emotion, it comes and goes. But happiness is more than this, it can be a perpetual state of consciousness and comes in parallel to emotions.
- parylose 8y agoThat reminds me of a Billy Joel (singer) interview. He said he was always asked if he was happy now and he stressed out when he couldn't answer yes. He ended up pursuing happiness at high cost. He eventually realized just because he wasn't happy didn't mean he was sad. Happiness and sadness are extremes. Most of the time you just are. He learned to just be and appreciate the happy times.
- CrazyPyroLinux 8y agoThe Oatmeal did a great comic on this, which I think illustrates your point perfectly: https://theoatmeal.com/static/unhappy.html https://theoatmeal.com/static/unhappy.html
- djKianoosh 8y agoRight on. It's the difference between temporary joy/contentment and true happiness.
- _fuck_you 8y agoThanks for the sage wisdom. My life is changed. All right here on HN. Wow.
- PakG1 8y agoVery true, but once you make the decision, all those other things are multipliers. Just unfortunately, if you make the negative decision, well the negative still multiplies too.... hence the divorces and all the drama at work.... If you took away my marriage and job, I would be markedly more unhappy. I imagine if I ever have a big wad of cash sitting around, I would be a bit less happy if that disappeared too (only because keeping it around certainly would only keep me at the status quo, if not make me more happy). What's that they say about coming into a lot of money, that it just reveals who your true self is? And yes, some people get into crappy marriages or crappy jobs where they just get knocked down 24/7. But I've observed that negative people easily self-prophesy into negative situations far more often than positive people. edit: added points
- nismoskyz 8y ago"But I've observed that negative people easily self-prophesy into negative situations far more often than positive people." Very much agree with this.
- untilHellbanned 8y agoIt's not a choice.
- metabagel 8y agoI think that I would say that we can't choose to be happy, but we can choose to be content, and we can choose not to dwell in sadness. We can allow our emotions to fluctuate and not stay fixed in depression. We do this by not fixing our thoughts, and by being open to the present moment.
- simonh 8y agoThen what is it? Jordan Peterson, who for a long time I wrote off as a crackpot until I actually paid attention to some of his interviews and lectures, talks a lot about this. Happiness is a pretty crappy goal to have. It's a side effect of pursuing actual, worthwhile goals. People need to take some responsibility for their own state of mind and the things they are choosing to do that affect it.
- nkozyra 8y ago> Then what is it? It's a response. Internal responses, sure, but also - and more dramatically - to external ones. > Jordan Peterson, who for a long time I wrote off as a crackpot Trust your initial instincts ;)
- simonh 8y agoSome of what he says is a bit disturbing, but he has a lot of statistics and cites a lot of sources that seem very credible, and I've yet to come across any counter-arguments that are anything more than incredulity and ideology. I'd love to see a plausible and knowledgeable counter argument.
- moorhosj 8y agoWhat is the argument you want to see countered?
- newsgremlin 8y agoThe focus should be on living in the present, that's the only place you will find happiness. And if you pass by those moments without appreciation, you'll only feel regret and anxiously wait for the next bit of happiness to be found.
- tootie 8y agoI think "choose" isn't even the right term. Everyone has it in them to be happy, but it's way harder for some people than others.
- snarf21 8y agoThis reminds me of a quote from Stewart Brand during an interview with Tim Ferris. ".... and being proud is the most reliable source of happiness that I know."[https://tim.blog/2018/02/03/the-tim-ferriss-show-transcripts-stewart-brand/ https://tim.blog/2018/02/03/the-tim-ferriss-show-transcripts...] Teach yourself how to cook, get in shape, draw a picture, write a story, help someone less fortunate, teach someone something you know, learn how to juggle... In the end it doesn't really matter what it is but you will have that proud feeling and be happy in that moment. Rinse and repeat.
- Baeocystin 8y agoSpeaking strictly for myself, I have not found this to be true. I do enjoy collecting skills, and learning is fun. But no matter what the skill, eventually you hit the wall of diminishing returns, and I find that pride in that last 1-2% of performance is not worth the cost in time; I would rather improve a weaker skill another 10-20% with the same amount of training. And fundamentally, I find pride a bit too solipsistic to be truly satisfying no matter what the skill. What I have found permanently effective is practicing gratefulness. Every day I make it a point to think of things that I am genuinely grateful to have, or to have experienced. This (for me), more than anything else, helps put my mind at ease, and allow me to enjoy the life that I have.
- marmadukester39 8y agoI agree. The challenge for me has been that in practicing gratitude I find myself fearing the loss of the things for which I am grateful even more.
- Baeocystin 8y agoI can't say I am 100% great at following my own advice, here, but I do find that it helps to try and focus on experiences that I am grateful for instead of physical things, and for much the same reason as what you give- you can't have experiences taken away in the same manner as a physical thing.
- 8y ago
- beat 8y agoHappiness is not a choice. If you think it is, try learning more about clinical depression.
- bradstewart 8y agoNot OP, but I took the comment in the context of your average healthy person. An illness absolutely affects the equation. I don't think anyone is suggesting depression is a choice.
- Liquix 8y agoSome people's brain chemistry makes feeling happiness much more difficult. Some people with clinical depression will physically never experience happiness the same way others do. That's true and valid. But does that really mean that being happy is not a choice? A paraplegic is unable to choose to move their legs due to a medical condition - would they assert that 'moving your legs is not a choice'?
- chongli 8y agoI'm extremely skeptical of the brain chemistry narrative. It doesn't explain why depression is growing rapidly in the Western world. It doesn't explain why antidepressants vary so widely in their efficacy between persons. I'm far more apt to believe that people's lives are getting worse and that they're depressed as a result. People are lonelier than ever and society's problems are bigger and more abstract than ever. We're no longer even cogs in a machine, we're atoms in a cog. Meaning in life has become extremely elusive.
- Liquix 8y agoI completely agree. As Chamath Palihapitiya (ex-Facebook) eloquently puts it, our technology culture is 'ripping apart the social fabric of how society works' [0]. We're social creatures who thrive on human interaction and sharing genuine moments - social media gives us the exact opposite [1]. The really insidious thing is that many of the big players and driving forces behind these trends saw it coming, knew that what they were building may have far-reaching negative consequences, and then chose to do it anyway for the sake of money. What a time to be alive, right? [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78oMjNCAayQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78oMjNCAayQ [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4853817/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4853817/