5 ms·
On the other hand, fusion/fission have the advantage of also working at night. Solar is cheap during the day, but at night it's the cost of solar + storage infr
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
On the other hand, fusion/fission have the advantage of also working at night. Solar is cheap during the day, but at night it's the cost of solar + storage infrastructure + conversion losses.
It's also theoretically possible that working fusion could be cheaper than fission, because fission is as expensive as it is as a result of the perverse coalition of confused environmentalists and self-interested fossil fuel companies lobbying to make it expensive on purpose. But fusion doesn't have long-lived nuclear waste to contend with (not that modern fission reactors do either) and the fossil fuel industry is going to decline one way or another, so that leaves fusion (and fission) with more hope in the future, if the regulations can be fixed once the lobby for them to be purposely stupid wanes.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shaki-dora 8y ago> perverse coalition of confused environmentalists I actually don't see how environmentalist have had any impact on the cost of fission. Unless, of course, you're just considering all safety costs the result of "confused environmentalists". If so, you should seriously consider if you have maybe adopted some sort of perverted scientism as a quasi-religion. Because in reality, there's essentially consensus regarding required safety measures within the community of actual nuclear scientists, who have always been the driving force behind improved safety–starting with Richard Feynman during the Manhattan Project.
- nickik 8y agoLiterally the whole nuclear industry government, private and the public went pretty crazy after Three Mile Island and doubled down on those mistakes with Chernobyl. There was a massive bias against nuclear on pretty much every level. Fortunately this is now changing slowly (GAIN for example), at least in the government. Pretty much any not so well informed person is against nuclear, and most of them can not say why other then some wage Greenpeace slogan that is simply scientifically inaccurate. Regulation is insanely high for lots of stuff that really is not safety critical. Citing for a nuclear project is insanely difficult. The regulated energy market (in the US) simply does not value long term 100 year assets in the way they are set up. Nuclear cites are discriminated against in terms of low carbon benefits and tax credits (Solar gets tax credit when dispatching negatively priced energy). Nuclear cites get routinely sued and the environmentalist know that every month of delay is costing them millions, because up front capital has massive interest. Innovation has come to a virtual stand still, regulation has made it essentially impossible to innovate in nuclear for anything but the most incremental changes. The government has utterly failed at coming up with anything regarding nuclear 'waste', and instead of using one of the many straight forward solution is is basically in political limbo while the nuclear plants still pay millions to the government every year. If you even want the nuclear regulatory body to take a look at your new design, you have to pay them a lot of money. If you want them to actually regulate it, they will say 'Ok thanks, we get back to you in the next couple of years we don't know how long its gone take and remember that's gone cost you 100 million at least'. The regulation have hard coded in them that a reactor needs to have certain features, like 'Must have system to cool steam'. Now great, what if my reactor isn't water cooled? Well, pay them a couple 100 million more and 10-20 years and they can probably work out what regulations they would apply to your design. People couldn't build the old designs cheaply and they couldn't design new ones without the government leading the way to a commercial system it was impossible. Nuclear was on target of replacing fossil fuels in energy production and was growing exponentially and was on target to be the fastest energy transition in human history and then 1 single safety failure that killed nobody wiped out that whole tech tree (Yes that's overly dramatic). So, I agree more safety regulations were needed, but instead the nuclear industry was basically killed, practically every outstanding project (and there were many) was cancelled and almost no nuclear plants have been built after that. The few that have been built are often close to existing once. At the same time, coal plants that are MUCH, MUCH more radioactive are allowed to operate. In fact, a nuclear plant that was as radioactive as a coal plant would not be allowed to operate AT ALL.
- bewo001 8y agoWhat if wind/solar + inefficient storage, conversion losses still turn out to be cheaper than fusion? I'm all for doing fusion research, but fusion might be a completely uneconomical solution to the energy problem.