3 ms·
EU is 500M people Saudi Arabia is 40M Also, GDPR doesn’t ‘almost definitely violates the first amendment’, GDPR wasn’t passed by Congress. A GDPR-like rule mig
by krstf13 8y ago
EU is 500M people Saudi Arabia is 40M
Also, GDPR doesn’t ‘almost definitely violates the first amendment’, GDPR wasn’t passed by Congress. A GDPR-like rule might violate the first amendment if you allow a really extensive definition of speech, and even in such a setting there would be a lot of room to argue.
- ng12 8y ago> GDPR wasn’t passed by Congress. That's the point. Neither were SA's censorship laws. You have to conform to laws that wouldn't fly in the USA to do business in other countries.
- krstf13 8y agoI don’t think it’s a valid comparison though because market sizes aren’t the same and because viewing GDPR as a free speech is far from obvious (it actually requires yogi master like bending abilities) You could argue that anti hate speech laws in some European countries (eg France) are the same. It’s also not necessarily correct that ‘you have to conforms to laws ... to do business in other countries’. Many trades treaties supersede local laws also, when there’s political will it’s perfectly possible to restrict what private businesses can do abroad (eg Iran).
- ng12 8y ago> market sizes aren’t the same I'm not sure why this matters, I'm sure they make enough money from SA users to justify region-locking specific episodes. > it’s perfectly possible to restrict what private businesses can do abroad This is not relevant. An appropriate example would be a company operating in a foreign country where they willfully ignore that country's laws.