3 ms·
I am struck by the clarity and simplicity of Dyson's writing. As to the substance: yes, hiding your work under a bushel does nobody any favor, but it's underst
by gumby 8y ago
I am struck by the clarity and simplicity of Dyson's writing.
As to the substance: yes, hiding your work under a bushel does nobody any favor, but it's understandable when it feels like the alternative is the strident trumpeting of trivial "advancements".
But also cautionary is the constraints due to the wrong metaphors. We often see this today in linear predictions as to the impact of some new idea. It's easy to mock Ballmer when he laughed at the iphone back in 2007 (back when this essay was written). But his comment made sense for his customer base. He (and nor could Apple) couldn't really see that the game was changing.
Dyson points out that Maxwell himself had the same problem.
- hopler 8y agoWhy would you say Apple, whose main business was an extensive traxk record in creating, promoting, and selling next generation technology, that their major investment in a new field was blind speculation? In contrast to Microsoft whose business was providing stable solutions and extracting monopoly rents.
- aj7 8y agoThis is (1) False, or a venomous mid-80s position. (2) Irrelevant to the theory of electromagnetism.
- gumby 8y agoNot sure I understand your point. Mine was that in science or business we are often held back from understanding by the limitations of our models, even when we ourselves are the inventors. I thought I used an example well known to HN to make the point. Apple’s stated hope was to eventually have 1% of the market (and they didn’t originally plan for an App Store). Like Maxwell, they didn’t know they had a blockbuster. Microsoft listened very closely to their customers, who were and are mainly corporate I/T and something like the iphone wasn’t something they said they wanted. In fact it honestly had no affordances that IT wanted. Maxwell understood the math but his own mechanical metaphor distracted him, and other physicists too, so that they couldn’t really see the larger implications.
- icebraining 8y agoan example well known to HN I think the issue is that example doesn't seem to be true.. Jobs said at the time of launch that it was a revolutionary and magical product which was five years ahead of everyone else and would change everything. And the hope wasn't to have 1% eventually, but by the end of 2008.