2 ms·
So Signal and others are not "homebrew crypto"? That criticism is fair a lot of times, but every higher level crypto construction is going to be unproven for a
by raverbashing 8y ago
So Signal and others are not "homebrew crypto"?
That criticism is fair a lot of times, but every higher level crypto construction is going to be unproven for a while until checked.
It's not like they were inventing their own hash function and stream cypher.
- tptacek 8y agoSignal is the best-studied multiparty secure messaging protocol; there are academic papers that provide formal analyses. Trevor and Moxie won the Levchin Prize at Real World Crypto for Signal Protocol; the Levchin steering committee is a "Who's Who" of cryptographers, as are the other winners of the prize. No, Signal is not "homebrew crypto".
- raverbashing 8y agoWhat would be a good definition of Homebrew crypto? Sure, if I put some primitives together (even if I had a good knowledge of how to do it) in a closed product and nobody evaluates it (and I add a label like "military security") that's Homebrew, no questions. But all systems are born "in secret" (at least for a short while). Unless the definition involves appeal to authority.
- tptacek 8y agoObviously, the term is a straightforward appeal to authority.
- raverbashing 8y agoWhich is sometimes unjustly described as fallacious, though even the best can make mistakes.
- tptacek 8y agoHopefully we agree on the authority here. But I jumped the gun on my response a little as well, because my argument isn't simply an appeal to authority; for instance, you can just go read the formal analyses of Signal Protocol and evaluate them for yourself. Maybe IEEE EuroS&P was wrong to accept the paper!