7 ms·
Growing Caltrain into an 8-Lane Freeway (2018)
- masonic 8y agoYou have to drill down into the tiny About link at bottom right to find that this is not an official Caltrain site at all: "I do not work in the rail transport industry. I have no relationship with the CHSRA or any of its engineering consultants, whether personal, professional or financial."
- marcinzm 8y agoCaltrain seems to be thinking along similar lines although who knows how much of this will pan out: https://www.caltrain2040.org/wp-content/uploads/CBP_November_LPMG_Presentation.pdf https://www.caltrain2040.org/wp-content/uploads/CBP_November...
- gumby 8y agoFWIW it's a blogspot post and doesn't look like an official Caltrain post in any way to me.
- jessriedel 8y agoYea, it would have been nice to have more author information up top so I knew who I was listening to, but I never was put under the impression it was an official Caltrain blog.
- marcinzm 8y agoFor those interested in what Caltrain itself thinks here's their latest presentation on plans and expectations for 2040 (which was put out after the linked blog post): https://www.caltrain2040.org/wp-content/uploads/CBP_November_LPMG_Presentation.pdf https://www.caltrain2040.org/wp-content/uploads/CBP_November... Caltrain thinks on the high end they can get ~243k daily riders by 2040 up from the current 62k. That's actually a bigger capacity growth (3.9x versus 2.9x) than the blog is talking about although the blog only goes up to 2035.
- addcn 8y agoI spend a lot of time in all the major cities and what strikes me about the Bay Area is how geographically constrained the suburbs are. You basically get degrees of freedom to the South and North (and some in the East Bay) but unlike NYC you can’t spread out in all directions. I’ve never formally studied this in detail but my intuition says geography led to many of the Bay’s housing and transportation problem. When viewed through that lens this superhighway of Caltrain makes sense. Not rocket science but thought I’d share.
- filesystemdude 8y agoConstrained geography is an important part of shaping cities, but it's generally considered by geographers and urban planners to be an enormous positive.
- marcinzm 8y agoI'm curious why that's the case and under what conditions it applies. Constrained geography means that, physically, you can fit fewer people within the same commuting time which means prices should go up faster given demand than otherwise. Given an external source of demand (ie: hot area for whatever reason) that seems a bad combination for a healthy city.
- gumby 8y agoIt suppresses sprawl. If you allow people to build (an issue on the peninsula) then you can provide services more efficiently with less environmental impact.
- llukas 8y ago> that seems a bad combination for a suburb FTFY. Healthy city requires density - enough density means you got most things you need within walking distance.
- marcinzm 8y agoSure but then you get past that density into territory where the price per square foot means everyone lives in shoe boxes and/or is priced out. Higher density costs more money per square foot to build.
- mc32 8y agoI’d love to see the Bay Area agencies take the bitter pill and do a cut-and-cover for BaRT all the way down the El Camino from SF/DC to SJ. Alas, I know it isn’t going to happen, but it could and it’d be great. It’d serve more people and would be more convenient than Caltrain's right-of-way.
- melling 8y agoMore cars? Trying to figure out how to get more cars on the road? That’s been the plan since the 1970’s. Maybe they should have built the high-speed rail like they wanted at that time. It becomes more difficult and expensive as the decades progress.
- mc32 8y agoNo, they're saying Caltrain would contribute the same as 8 lanes worth of freeway commuter volume. But I think BaRT would be a better solution than Caltrain, if they put BaRT down the El Camino as it would serve a higher pop and would be closer to pop centers.
- i_am_proteus 8y agoDoes the soil support cut-and-cover? Most Bay Area homes I've seen don't have a basement, and I've always assumed that's for a reason.
- melling 8y agoSan Francisco to San Jose is about 50 miles. I’d say somewhere around 2060 that becomes a 20 minute commute. The future will eventually get here.
- joejerryronnie 8y agoOr, once companies embrace remote work like they should, it becomes a 10 step commute from my bedroom to my office.
- crushcrashcrush 8y agoI find public transportation in the bay area to quite literally be an intractable problem. I've lived here for 31 years and there's been zero, and I mean zero real progress. BART received a warm springs extension and a couple (non-connected) airport trams. The highways are largely unchanged (excluding highway 237, maybe) NIMBYs in Palo Alto, Atherton, Menlo Park, etc will block any true expansion or creation of public transit on the peninsula. Reminder: we don't have electrified Caltrain because of Atherton. Hence, I've made a decision - move elsewhere. Literally anywhere else has better public transportation. NYC/Chicago/Los Angeles/Portland/Seattle/Austin/Miami I wish it would change, but your best bet is to simply move closer to work here, if that means leaving your single family home in Fremont to a townhome in Sunnyvale. Another example: There's already rail infrastructure in place parallel to the Dumbarton bridge from Fremont to East Palo Alto / Palo Alto. Plans were in place - see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumbarton_Rail_Corridor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumbarton_Rail_Corridor We can't seem to get anything done.
- jacques_chester 8y ago> We can't seem to get anything done. From a distant outside perspective, my impression is that nothing will ever be done, short of a cataclysmic upheaval (political or geographic). The major barriers are that there is no single polity for the Bay Area and that there are multiple rail systems. Small polities resist mergers because they (correctly) deduce that their local wishes will be overridden by a wider collective need. Multiple public rail systems won't be merged. Unlike private rail, they don't have economic pressure to merge and have independent sources of existence (state vs federal legislation, for example).
- eganist 8y ago> NYC/Chicago/Los Angeles/Portland/Seattle/Austin/Miami DC and Chicago are notably absent from your list despite being better than all but one city on your list with public transit. Pay these both a visit. And don't oversell Austin's public transit system :) As an aside, it does fascinate me that DC Metro (WMATA) and BART were built from largely the same pattern and yet DC managed to rehab itself quite significantly while BART hasn't come close. We don't have nearly the same amount of NIMBY going on here, so your correlation might hold pretty well when comparing these two markets specifically.
- cududa 8y agoHas this person every y’know looked out the window while riding on a Caltrain? The cost alone to acquire the properties adjacent to the tracks would be astronomical
- jcranmer 8y agoYou do realize that this is talking about only using the current two-track rail geometry and not about ballooning the size of the track to that of a large highway?
- OxO4 8y agoPresumably, this could all be done without extending the footprint of the rails already present just by increasing the number of trains, cars per train, speed of the trains, or improving the design of the cars. Really, the beauty of public transportation is that you can get much higher density (and speed) than individual transportation if done correctly.
- andr 8y agoBeyond the morning and evening commutes, when there is standing room for the middle part of the commute, CalTrain is usually about 1/5th full during the day time, even when it only runs one train per hour. Something tells me "freeway lane" capacity is not limiting factor. The train is slow (San Jose - San Francisco takes over 90 minutes, or a little over 30mph). It is also infrequent with trains running 1-2 times an hour on the minor stops, meaning that unless you can schedule your day entirely around the CalTrain schedule, you'll be stuck waiting for it a lot. Fixing this will require more than electrification and CalTrain projects achieving 110mph speeds in 2040 (realistically 2050-2060).
- Tempest1981 8y agoWe should shut down the HSR project (train from SF to LA), and redirect the funds ($77 billion) to improve regional transit. When CHSR (California High Speed Rail) was approved by 52.6% of voters in 2008, the estimated price was around $40 billion. Now that cost estimates are at $77 billion (and on track for $100 billion), voters should be allowed a "vote of no confidence". Imagine what we could do with $100 billion.