5 ms·
The issue with using data about a 90% style tax rates is that nobody will ever be paying that rate. Why would anyone continue working for an income if they were
by roenxi 8y ago
The issue with using data about a 90% style tax rates is that nobody will ever be paying that rate. Why would anyone continue working for an income if they were paying 90% of it in tax? They'd find some way of organising their affairs so that they are compensated in some manner that is not income, or they'd stop working.
Eg, Maybe a company director is being paid $300,000 per annum, then a 90% tax rate for incomes >$100,000 is bought in. Suddenly his wife and son have a job at the company as advisors on $100,000 per annum each, their jobs are remarkably work-lite, and the director's salary drops to $100,000. Adjust as needed to be compliant with local law.
- harryh 8y agoUntaxed fringe benefits (company car, extravagant meals on the company dime, etc) were much more common in the US when we had very high marginal tax rates on large incomes.
- bryanlarsen 8y ago"Why would anyone continue working for an income if they were paying 90% of it in tax?" The average American has already spent most or all of their wage before they receive it. 40 cents in taxes, 35 cents in rent, 8 cents for food, ... If they're lucky, they can spend 5 cents of that dollar on something of their choice. Whereas if they get an extra dollar "bonus" from their job, that dollar is unallocated and they can allocate it however they want. So that extra 10 cents from the marginal dollar at a rate of 90% may be worth "more" to them than the dollar they earned at the lower base rate. "They'd find some way of organising their affairs so that they are compensated in some manner that is not income," The rich will spend a lot of effort on tax avoidance and tax evasion whether the tax rate is 35% or 70%.
- roenxi 8y ago> The average American has already spent most or all of their wage before they receive it. 40 cents in taxes, 35 cents in rent, 8 cents for food, ... If they're lucky, they can spend 5 cents of that dollar on something of their choice. You can't claim that 60c in the dollar of non-tax spending is somehow equivalent to a tax. I mean, the people who pay taxes are almost always experiencing a net transfer payment away from them to others, it isn't like anyone thinks it is sensible for the government to take 35c from the average American to provide 35c of rental assistance to the average American, everyone knows that is stupid. It only makes sense to tax if it is for a transfer payment from wealthy to poor, or to fund something communal, eg, infrastructure. Spending on things you will personally and exclusively enjoy is different from being taxed. 10c marginal is never going to be worth more to someone than their first few dollars, marginal utility goes down [0]. > The rich will spend a lot of effort on tax avoidance and tax evasion whether the tax rate is 35% or 70%. That is just vague and mean spirited. I'll accept that only the rich engage in tax avoidance/evasion, because it doesn't help poor people, but if you want to make a point here you are really going to need to provide a source or elaborate a bit. I think we'd find in practice that as the merginal rate rises, the rich would be more likely to engage in tax minimisation practices - and this is because at very high marginal rates how would anyone become rich while paying a punitive tax rate? [0] https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/12309/concepts/diminishing-marginal-utility-of-income-and-wealth/ https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/12309/concepts/diminishin...