3 ms·
It doesn't really follow that tax policy should be different because a diverse population disagrees more. With the exception of point 3 (which actually does ap
by jayd16 8y ago
It doesn't really follow that tax policy should be different because a diverse population disagrees more. With the exception of point 3 (which actually does apply to the US as well) you could make this argument about any policy.
- charlesism 8y agoIf anything, it puts the cart before the horse. Economic inequality increases tribalism.
- roenxi 8y ago> you could make this argument about any policy It is completely reasonable to say that good policy for 10 million people is different from good policy for 100 million people. Not all effects caused by increasing population scale in the same way. Economic geography is a very interesting subject and certainly admits the possibility for small, high-skill nations to be able to enjoy a localised prosperity that doesn't scale very well. > It doesn't really follow that tax policy should be different because a diverse population disagrees more I don't follow what you mean with that. A divided polity will produce a very different set of policy than a united polity. There is no convincing science, theory or philosophy setting what taxes should be. Taxes are what they are, and we've seen arguably successful societies at a wide range of tax levels. A small united polity will clearly be more successful at using government to achieve their aims than a large and disparate population.
- jayd16 8y agoIts not that the argument is impossible. The issue is that it's just a hypothetical with no backing presented as fact. Some policies cannot scale from 10 million to 100 million, but some can. No work is put into proving that this particular policy cannot scale.
- rayiner 8y ago> It doesn't really follow that tax policy should be different because a diverse population disagrees more. I don't think it's much of a stretch to say that people are more okay with giving the government more control of their money in societies where people tend to be similarly situated and have similar values.
- hoaw 8y agoI wouldn't overestimate homogeneity as a reason for the Swedish welfare state. The strong Swedish state probably goes back to the nationalization, and later decreased influence, of the Swedish church. That standing was later used by the Social Democrats (among others) to reform Sweden to a welfare state. Today, as those ideas are becoming less popular it is relatively apparent that Swedes don't give a shit about each other more than anyone else. The political parties can't even form a government since the last election.
- jayd16 8y agoIt's not impossible but its just conjecture presented as fact.