3 ms·
> How do you know if it would be stupid and ineffective? Because you can already pay more taxes than required in many places, and (almost) nobody does so. > P
by lern_too_spel 8y ago
> How do you know if it would be stupid and ineffective?
Because you can already pay more taxes than required in many places, and (almost) nobody does so.
> Perhaps he’s representative of rich people who want to pay more tax.
He is representative — he doesn't pay more than is required. He is proposing that the government require people like him to pay more taxes, which would mean that low income people pay less.
- zepto 8y ago> Because you can already pay more taxes than required, and nobody does so. There are lots of things people can do but don’t until a social movement encourages them to do so. Charities for example don’t receive donations until someone makes a case for why they should. Also, I’m not sure why you think that raising taxes on one group automatically results in other groups being taxed less. That isn’t typically how it works.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> Also, I’m not sure why you think that raising taxes on one group automatically results in other groups being taxed less. That isn’t typically how it works. That is exactly how it works. The state has the same expenses and must fund them somehow. Reducing taxes for one group doesn't magically make those expenses go away. When one group pays less, other groups pay more. Similarly, when one group pays more, others pay less. The state doesn't magically have more expenses.
- zepto 8y agoNope. I recommend you spend some time researching this. Tax has never worked the way you describe. When states take in more tax than their expenses, they run a surplus. When they take in less, they run a deficit. Usually when they run a surplus, they find ways to spend it after not too long. Raising taxes on any particular group or activity has no direct effect on the other tax rates.
- lern_too_spel 8y ago> When states take in more tax than their expenses, they run a surplus. When they take in less, they run a deficit. Usually when they run a surplus, they find ways to spend it after not too long. Those ways to spend it typically help the poor, so taxing the rich more helps the poor. The money doesn't magically disappear.
- zepto 8y agoSo you agree that what you said before about how taxes work was just plain wrong.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoIt was absolutely correct. The state can increase its expenses, but it doesn't happen automatically when the tax code changes. The main point is that when one group pays more, other groups benefit more.
- zepto 8y agoYou said this: “Similarly, when one group pays more, others pay less. The state doesn't magically have more expenses.” And that is absolutely false. Also, there is certainly no relationship between raising taxes and the poor benefiting. The money can be wasted or spent on the military, etc.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoWhat I said is absolutely correct. When the money is wasted on the military, the poor still benefit more than if the money hadn't been taken from the rich and spent on the military. You are also still confusing taxes with spending.