10 ms·
There is no question that public stadium subsidies are almost always a bad investment. However these type of articles never take into consideration that people
by slg 8y ago
There is no question that public stadium subsidies are almost always a bad investment. However these type of articles never take into consideration that people generally like sports teams and want them to stay in the same region. It also isn't just people who attend the games or businesses around the stadium. A local sports team, unlike nearly any other private business, provides a huge but unknown amount of utility to a wide range of residents who never pay for a ticket or a piece of merchandise. Is it unreasonable for a sports team to want to benefit from that free utility?
Politicians shouldn't buy all of these stupid economic arguments for a simple fact they are often wrong. But governments aren't businesses. They don't have to make the smart economic move on every single decision. Creating a public park is rarely a smart economic move, but cities do it because that is what residents want. Politicians who let a sports franchise leave town without putting up a fight in negotiations are often quickly voted out (as well as politicians who offer too many incentives for a team to stay). So the people clearly want to keep teams when the cost is reasonable. The problem is what is "reasonable", especially when there is another city a few states over that has a slightly more generous definition of "reasonable"?
TL;DR - It is more complicated than "sports stadiums = bad" but these discussions rarely get deeper than that.
- CamperBob2 8y agoTL;DR - It is more complicated than "sports stadiums = bad" but these discussions rarely get deeper than that. Additionally, the detractors often don't understand that these things are basically urban pacification projects. The argument has been made that having a place where the mayor sits down with a businessman on one side and a bricklayer on the other, where everybody has temporarily set aside their differences in politics, occupation, wealth, class, IQ, gender, religion, what-have-you and is lustily cheering for the same outcome, is good for social order. To the extent that's true, it makes stadiums a valid subject for government funding. I don't like sportsball and I don't like being forced to pay for it, but I also can't see how to shoot any holes in this argument. It makes some sense.
- smelendez 8y agoIt also benefits an area to have regional cohesion. I'm sure having the big local city and all its suburbs rooting for the home team helps with that.
- mattchew 8y agoYou can always make up a story where your project brings intangible but wonderful benefits that no decent person could be against. This is normal. If you can paint a rosy picture of community, or the happiness of children, or the safety of the vulnerable, it is indeed very hard to argue against. Saying the glowing vision is exaggerated or fabulated just makes you look like a grouch and a jerk. In my town, the new stadium has a VIP area. Important people are specifically shielded from contact with bricklayers. Just saying.
- CamperBob2 8y agoSaying the glowing vision is exaggerated or fabulated just makes you look like a grouch and a jerk. Yep. Unfortunately, the people who want to treat stadiums as public works projects have 2000+ years of history on their side going back to classical Rome and Athens. I've concluded that it's not a battle worth fighting, if only because my lack of appreciation of team sports makes me a bad judge of how important they are to society.
- kijin 8y agoPanem et circenses. Massive "sports" events have been a staple of social control since Greek and Roman times, and still are to some extent. Instead of going out and killing people on the streets, you just watch gladiators kill one another. People still riot from time to time when their favorite team loses a big match, but those riots can be much more easily controlled and condemned than one that actually exposes deep fissures within the society. Having said that, however, it's worth asking whether a democratic society should allow the government to encourage such a well-known method of silencing dissent.
- ksdale 8y agoThis is a very underrated point. I feel like in the abstract, we should be asking how much a city should be willing to pay for a place where tens of thousands of people can gather for a common purpose tens of times a year to attend an activity that tens (or hundreds) of thousands more people really enjoy watching on TV. It seems very plausible that this should be a non zero amount. (Also plausible that it shouldn’t be in the billions...) A lot of people think sports are not a worthy use of government funds, which I totally understand. But looking past the relative pointlessness of most sports, it really is an exceptional experience to be in a packed stadium whether it’s for a football game or a concert or whatever.
- ken 8y agoOne big difference is that artists pay to use a venue for a performance. Sports teams get the city to pay to build the stadium, and keep the profits. When I go to the theatre or the symphony or the ballet or the opera, the programs and the placards in the lobby always make it clear that most of their funding comes from donations from big companies (in Seattle: always Boeing and Microsoft) and private donors. If we're so excited to spend public money for gatherings at events that people want to see, why don't they ever spend that sort of money on the arts? Why don't I see Seattle Pops concerts on TV? Why do we depend on private donations to keep the theatres open? Why do we zone for stadiums, but not community theatre? Everyone I know wants to see more of these performing artists but most have trouble affording tickets. When you can't afford an NFL ticket, you turn on the TV and watch it for free anyway. When you can't afford to see the local arts, you're mostly just SOL.
- slg 8y agoDo you think there is a conspiracy to keep local art off TV? Or maybe the reason that you don't see the Seattle Pops on TV more is because broadcasters can't make money since people won't watch them? Sports are popular. That always seems to be a shock to people in the type of circles that frequent HN, but it is the underlying fact that allows sports teams to get these subsidizes in the first place.
- 8y ago
- rland 8y agoAwesome comment, and I legitimately have never heard this point of view before. You're right, the closest it ever gets is "don't you like [sports team]??" I'm far more inclined to change my view on this issue. We (San Diego) recently had a protracted fight for our sports team. They wanted a new stadium, the city didn't, they moved away. I voted against it. I probably still would have, just because I think the NFL is dead in the long run from all the TBI stuff.
- rossjudson 8y agoPlease say "false equivalence" to yourself, as many times as you can. You're going to compare a public park to a stadium? Go to a stadium without a ticket, and see for yourself just how "public" it is. Really, really large numbers of people use public parks. Small, small numbers of people (by percentage, in large metro regions) ever see the inside of a stadium. While I understand that there are many that enjoy professional sports, I certainly don't want my tax dollars supporting it.
- slg 8y agoYou are missing basically the whole point of my comment. You don't have to enter a stadium or even pay a cent to a sports team to get utility from it. You can watch a game on free over-the-air TV or you can enjoy the communal aspects that other comments in this thread have mentioned. The business is generating positive externalities and therefore it might be appropriate to subsidize it. Also, you might not want your tax dollars going to support professional sports, but many people do. That was my other point. We live in a democracy and the people generally are in favor of sports. The exact entertainment value it generates is debatable, but it is enough that these deals can be justified without requiring them to turn a profit. That was the only way I was comparing parks and stadiums. They don't need to be profitable to be a good use of money.
- Rapzid 8y agoThe game could be filmed in a comparatively cheap warehouse and you could still watch it on TV.
- snapdangle 8y ago> Also, you might not want your tax dollars going to support professional sports, but many people do. That was my other point. We live in a democracy and the people generally are in favor of sports. So let the taxpayers vote! If a majority wants to waste their money, then let them. But even then it is an absolute waste no matter your arguments because these are commercial entities backed by obscenely wealthy interests _that can afford to build them themselves_.
- 8y ago
- dionidium 8y agoNobody is confused about this point when the thing in question is highbrow (e.g. the symphony, opera, museums). We don’t get a lot of hot takes about how those are bad economic investments.
- emiliobumachar 8y agoThat's because we don't get many outright lies about how those are good economic decisions. They're usually framed honestly as "let's buy some culture".
- ericdykstra 8y agoI agree with you. Governments subsidize and pay for things with a lot less ROI than sports stadiums that can foster a sense of local community. Seattle spent $5 million making public shelters for drug deals and prostitution[1], and I bet most residents would have preferred that money go toward a new basketball/hockey arena. 1. https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/seattles-5-million-automated-public-toilets-sold-for-12000/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/seattles-5-million...
- notSupplied 8y agoThe problem is using the electoral mechanism rather than the market mechanism to determine how much we as a society should allocate to stadiums. In an electoral mechanism the 51% can compel the other 49% to spend tremendous resources on something the minority does not want. That is incredibly wasteful and those who want sports should pay for it directly via higher ticket prices instead. Also a lot of these are a zero-sum contest between cities to attract the teams who demand the new facilities. The economic value is transferred rather than created when two cities are bidding against each other. Same argument for bidding on Amazon HQ #2. Sports franchises and Amazon are leveraging their negotiating scale against local governments. Since cities cannot conduct "M&A", nor are they designed around the unyielding quest for growth, they will forever be out muscled by large businesses. This kind of subsidy simply needs to be illegal, as most cities are never in a strong negotiating position against private interests.