4 ms·
Well, sure. That works if these things are unpopular. They're not. That's the problem. Lost in the discussion of how many hundreds of million dollars St. Lo
by ajross 8y ago
Well, sure. That works if these things are unpopular. They're not. That's the problem.
Lost in the discussion of how many hundreds of million dollars St. Louis lost in its relationship with the Rams is the fact that the city loved that team and the stadium construction was a huge deal and a big political victory.
The underlying flaw in the reasoning here is that it's all based on a personal feeling that "My government is spending my tax dollars on something I don't like but other people do". Well... yeah. That's the cost of living under a government. The government's job is fairness, not pleasing everyone.
- logifail 8y ago>> the city loved that team and the stadium construction was a huge deal and a big political victory Can you quantify "the city loved"? I'm sure the construction was "a huge deal", large construction projects almost always are. Something professional politicians choose to support != something that a majority of voters would choose to support, given the chance.
- cmorgan31 8y agoYou can’t quantify love or sentiment unless you accept brand loyalty and subjective measures. It seems like a silly thing to request but perhaps that is your point. If these were ballot initiatives for funding similar to public transport you would see a bit more rejections from anyone outside of the city centers. If we go by popular vote you will likely see most cities vote to keep their teams because we’ve all been raised to think of them as ours despite owning nothing.
- logifail 8y ago>> If we go by popular vote you will likely see most cities vote to keep their teams Source? >> because we’ve all been raised to think of them as ours despite owning nothing. Not sure why there should be a connection between public funding for teams and teams staying in any particular city. If all cities stopped public funding for privately-owned sports teams, the teams would still need a place to call "home". The owners would just be slightly less rich.
- cmorgan31 8y agoI’m not implicitly agreeing that a connection should exist, but I’m also not going to pretend it doesn’t. Sports are a huge part of American culture and is one of the least contentious elements. I don’t have a source which empirically states “most cities would vote for the team” other than brand loyalty statistics which don’t correlate perfectly to this conversation. I’m attempting to discuss the less tangible aspect of this arrangement and why it is a bit of a radical variable in anyone trying to address this lopsided agreement. If you discount sentiment you aren’t even attempting to see why sports teams appeal to people and why they haven’t revolted at the thought of subsidizing them. I am not speaking in favor of subsidizing them or maintaining a status quo but instead I am trying to help quantify a city’s love of a team. I won’t even broach the topic of college stadiums and athletic fees but it might be one area that does have research on this topic.
- SpikeDad 8y agoThe underlying flaw is that the public allows their politicians to spend their money on personal political victories. There's no payback for politicians that waste tax money either explicitly or via tax breaks. Nor for them misstating benefits or outright lying about them. So yea if politicians around the country are not held responsible then complaining is indeed a waste of time.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> That works if these things are unpopular. They're not. I don’t have a comprehensive statistic, but almost every time I read about stadium subsidies being put to a vote (or a poll), the funding is rejected [1][2][3][4]. [1] http://www.golocalprov.com/politics/golocal-statewide-poll-just-13of-rhode-islanders-strongly-support-funding-t http://www.golocalprov.com/politics/golocal-statewide-poll-j... [2] https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/07/28/poll-finds-nevada-residents-dont-want-a-taxpayer-funded-stadium/amp/ https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/07/28/poll-finds-... [3] https://www.ktnv.com/news/political/ktnvrasmussen-poll-voters-opposed-to-putting-taxpayer-money-up-on-potential-raiders-stadium https://www.ktnv.com/news/political/ktnvrasmussen-poll-voter... [4] https://amp.smh.com.au/politics/nsw/voter-revolt-on-stadiums-poses-threat-to-premier-20180316-p4z4rq.html https://amp.smh.com.au/politics/nsw/voter-revolt-on-stadiums...
- kodablah 8y agoHrmm, most of the time I've seen them on ballots locally they are approved.