3 ms·
> Heck, there are way too many ISPs allocating a single /64 in v6 land today First, ISPs are allocating them because they can. There are enough total /64 block
by paulddraper 8y ago
> Heck, there are way too many ISPs allocating a single /64 in v6 land today
First, ISPs are allocating them because they can. There are enough total /64 blocks for every living person to have a couple billion blocks.
Second, ISPs are allocating /64 blocks because they have to. Well, they don't have to, but there are 20 billion billion total /64 blocks. ISPs will run of capacity in their routing tables long before address blocks are exhausted.
> Having an unnecessarily large amount of addresses is a good thing
Agreed. Both 64-bit and 128-bit have unnecessarily large address spaces. But 32-bit is too few, though, and byte/word alignment is convenient. So 64-bit is convenient, unnecessarily large solution.
- Dagger2 8y agoThere's no requirement for ISPs to allocate /64 blocks. The requirement is that they allocate enough address space for all of their client's networks to use /64s. As such, all recommendations are for /56 at least (which takes up the exact same amount of space in their routing tables as /64 does: one entry). If v6 was 64 bits in total, then ISPs would need to be allocating something closer to /48s to users at a minimum... but can you really imagine ISPs giving /48s in a 64-bit space when many of those same ISPs don't even give something larger than /64 in a 128-bit space? And this is despite the fact that a /48-in-64-bits would be 256 networks of 256 IPs each, which is far smaller than a /56's 256 networks of 2^64 IPs each? We know from v4 that 256 IPs in a network is frequently too small. I'm just not convinced that 64 bits is enough, and I don't think we should expend this much effort deploying something that could be too small. Sure, it might be big enough with careful management, but I think it would be stupid to take the risk. If you were arguing for an 80 bit address space then I'd have a much harder time calling it a risk, but for some reason 80 bits is an incredibly unpopular length.
- paulddraper 8y agoI misunderstood your criticism; I thought the blocks were too small.