2 ms·
> I knew what I wanted from the beginning: a rounded, translucent menu with a drop shadow. Minor nit, but I hate this effect because it's not how lighting work
by crazygringo 8y ago
> I knew what I wanted from the beginning: a rounded, translucent menu with a drop shadow.
Minor nit, but I hate this effect because it's not how lighting works. As the author discovers when it's implemented: "But what if your view casts a drop shadow? Yeah, you get a nice blurred shadow. Gross."
There's no such thing as any physical material which lets light through... and magically casts a shadow surrounding it but not behind it. It's uncanny-valley wrongness.
The way translucency is handled in macOS is bizarre. For example, the Finder side panel lets a small amount of your desktop image through... even when there's another window in the way. Which makes zero sense physically and hurts my brain.
I don't mind translucency if it's not overused... but I mind it when it doesn't obey physics. You can't unsee it.
- droopyEyelids 8y agoImagine sunshine from an oblique angle on matte glass. The matte surface defuses the light, making the translucent object brighter than the background.
- crazygringo 8y agoYes, that's exactly what the original article called "gross" because it's casting a shadow behind, as real physics would do (because the translucent object is brighter and reflecting light back). The author wants to have a shadow around the edges but somehow not a shadow behind the object itself, which is what doesn't make sense.
- ianai 8y agoI like that sort of thing because otherwise I never see my background image. Being able to see what’s behind a window through correct transparency does have usability features, though.