4 ms·
The government believes the law, with its checks and balances, is not strong enough to prevent attacks. The law prefers letting 9 guilty people walk free if tha
by tinus_hn 8y ago
The government believes the law, with its checks and balances, is not strong enough to prevent attacks. The law prefers letting 9 guilty people walk free if that prevents one innocent person from being unfairly punished. You can’t allow 9 hijackers to attack just to avoid not allowing one person to fly.
As the government is limited by the law they use tricks to go around it, in this case by using a secret list with secret rules and contents. You’re not allowed to know the list exists so you can’t contest if you are on it by mistake. There can be no precedent that allows people to remove themselves from the list.
- NullPrefix 8y agoWhy all this costly nonsense? Executing the person on the spot would surely be more time and resource effective. It would also serve as a better deterrent.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoBecause murder is illegal. Making your life impossible in and outside the justice system is not, as shown by this case. The government pays the legal fees, not the FBI agent or DOJ lawyers. Edit: My comment was meant to say that this was /is a loophole so the Gov stays "within the law." Killing you is obviously illegal, using their entire power to ruin you is not because they try 1000 arguments before the courts. May the truth win....er, if you have the time and tens of million$.
- NullPrefix 8y ago>Because murder is illegal What? Who cares about that. We aren't talking about regular citizens, but about people on no fly lists. Only terrorists get there
- T3OU-736 8y agoBut govt can write laws. After all, that is good the oft-abused NSLs are part of Patriot Act. Are you saying they the judiciary, upon seeing this law, would invalidate it at first opportunity?
- jcranmer 8y agoThe Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution says "No person shall […] be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law." Since the Constitution is the supreme law of the land, that provision trumps anything that the president or Congress can do short of passing another amendment to modify that. Denying a US citizen the right to travel without telling them why and preventing them from having any recourse to challenge it almost certainly violates that provision.
- jkartchner 8y agoIs access to the US "life, liberty, or property?" Does the Constitution apply to those outside "the land"? Often not.
- colejohnson66 8y ago> Does the Constitution apply to those outside "the land"? Often not. The Fifth Ammendment begins with “No person” not “No US citizen”
- jkartchner 8y agoThat's not how the courts often see it, though I admit it's been awhile since I've reviewed the caselaw
- jstanley 8y ago> You can’t allow 9 hijackers to attack just to avoid not allowing one person to fly. Yes you can, and should. That's the entire point of the idea that it is better to let 9 guilty people walk free than to unfairly punish one innocent person.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoNot only that, hijackers ceased to be a problem as soon as everyone understood they would crash the planes instead of ransoming them. It has always been the case that a plane full of passengers could overcome half a dozen hijackers, but the historical assumption was that you shouldn't fight them because you could get hurt. If you're going to get hurt anyway, that's out the window, so you fight them, so does everybody else, and the passengers win. You'll notice that there have been no further crashing of airplanes into buildings after 9/11, despite the fact that the TSA's security record is terrible.
- ohazi 8y agoAlso the steel fucking doors that block the entrance to the flight deck. The TSA shouldn't be looking for anything smaller than a plasma torch.
- jMyles 8y agoYou'll have to pry my plasma torch from my cold, dead... Oh, I can just check it and pick it up at baggage claim? Sounds good.
- njarboe 8y agoAnd Americans discovered, updated their thinking, and acted on this fact in about 25 minutes. Fight 93 was hijacked at 9:28am, by calling out the passengers knew that the New York attacks had happened a few minutes later, and at 9:54am passengers were breaking into the cockpit to stop the hijacker by force. Americans should have honored the heroes of flight 93, reminded each other that plane hijackers should now be fought directly, and the TSA never created with all of its waste and violations of civil liberties. Hopefully some near future government can find the strength to do this.