3 ms·
I fully realize I'm saying this because I'm not in that bracket, but if you make more than $10m/yr, do you really need the extra money that much?
by StavrosK 8y ago
I fully realize I'm saying this because I'm not in that bracket, but if you make more than $10m/yr, do you really need the extra money that much?
- zaroth 8y agoThis is a common misperception around the economics of taxation. Look at it from the company perspective. There is a skill that is worth a lot of money to them which they want to acquire. If they are willing to pay $1mm more than their competitor for that skil, for that amount of money to actually go to recipient, it will now cost the company $7mm of profit. That skill is no less valuable or essential to the company, it’s just effectively impossible to pay for it now. The extra money paid in taxes in order to acquire that skill comes off the balance sheet — and effectively is being taken away from the same pool of money that is being spent to hire workers at $50k/year. The $50k/year worker can not do the job of the $10mm/year worker. 100 of them cannot do the job either (because so much key labor is not actually divisible). It’s hurting the company balance sheet to effectively pay their most important employees, which hurts the company. Likewise, the employee making $10mm+ per year is a visionary who, like an Elon Musk, is contributing to the economy in ways a lot more profound than a few extra cents in everyone’s welfare checks. “No one needs more than a million dollars a year, just take everything above that to even things out” means you never have people willing to lay it all on the line to try to do something more as well.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- StavrosK 8y agoYour example overlooks a very important step, namely that no matter pays extra for that employee, the employee will have to pay 70% of it in taxes as well. No employee ever says "I have a job now, but if you want me, that will cost you an extra $1MM/yr". We go to the highest bidder, and whether the bid is pre-tax or post-tax makes no difference if the tax rate is the same no matter which company you work for.
- zaroth 8y agoExcept the tax rate isn’t the same everywhere or for every kind of dollar earned. And so it’s basically a ceiling on what that company can pay an employee versus what the employee could go make on their own or elsewhere. At $50k-$100k you can assume there are limits to what an employee can do. At $10m plus anything is on the table. So instead of taking a raise, I take a day off per week. Or two.
- giggles_giggles 8y agoDo the companies that you're starting or investing in with the $10m/yr you earn need that cash? Do you think Uncle Sam can do a better job of investing it than, say, Warren Buffett or Elon Musk? It's not like rich people just sit around on piles of money like Scrooge McDuck. They put that money to work so that they can earn some interest. The government will happily just spend it, though. So should it be doled out by congresspeople to their friends, or should it be invested by someone shrewd enough to be making $10m/yr in the first place?
- shadofx 8y agoIn the latter situation, the government will print the money they need for doling. Then everyone will be making >$10m/yr as the value of the dollar drops to zero.
- StavrosK 8y ago> They put that money to work so that they can earn some interest They put the money in things that will generate the highest return. The government will (hopefully) put the money in things that will benefit people, even if they don't have an especially high ROI in the short term. I am not at all confident in the ability of capitalism to save the environment, for example.
- cpeterso 8y agoFor example, how many billionaires have stepped up to fix Flint's water? Elon Musk did offer to send people water filters for their homes, but that doesn't address the root causes or the damage (property and health) already done. https://www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-flint-water-plan/ https://www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-flint-water-plan/
- DuskStar 8y agoAnd how many billionaires have filled a city's water with lead? "Look at this problem a government caused that those nasty rich people haven't fixed!" is not a fantastic argument for making them give more money to the government.