3 ms·
The problem is, this bill would have to pass the Senate - the current Senate. That seems... improbable. Even with a Democratic win in 2020, it seems improbabl
by AnimalMuppet 8y ago
The problem is, this bill would have to pass the Senate - the current Senate. That seems... improbable. Even with a Democratic win in 2020, it seems improbable without invoking the nuclear option. I'm not that deep into politics, so I'm not sure whether the nuclear option can be used on a bill like the proposed one. I'm also not clear whether small-state senators would vote for such a bill, even if they are Democrats.
- AvocadoPanic 8y agoNo. The Senate was created via legislation, you can't legislate it away. You'd have to amend the constitution.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoThe article was talking about a bill that (theoretically) would restructure the Senate without having to amend the Constitution. Even were that possible (about which I have doubts), my comment still stands.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The problem is, this bill would have to pass the Senate - the current Senate. That's a problem. To other problem is equal representation of States is express in the Constitution, and underlined by the provision ruling out amendments that would change it. The idea that the courts would somehow ignore the Constitutional requirement to allow a statute changing the apportionment to stand is ludicrous; it is especially ludicrous as an end-run against the provision barring changing the rule in the Constitution by amendment.