3 ms·
She cites Lincoln and FDR as evidence that radical ideas can be good ones. But "there have been radical ideas that have been good" does not imply "this radical
by AnimalMuppet 8y ago
She cites Lincoln and FDR as evidence that radical ideas can be good ones. But "there have been radical ideas that have been good" does not imply "this radical idea is a good one".
Her idea may in fact be good, but on this point, her logic does not work.
As for the idea itself: IIRC, there seem to be significant second-order effects that keep the federal government's income at 18-22% of GDP, no matter what the tax rates are. So raising the rates like this may provide significantly less new income than she expects.
What's more, if you have a pot of new money, there will be competing ideas for how to spend it. This green initiative may be a good idea. Somebody else may have a good idea - say, Medicare for all. And a different somebody may have another good idea - say, guaranteed basic income. The problem is, even if raising the taxes provides the expected money, the money is only enough for one of these ideas. You can only spend that pot once. But Congress being Congress, they're going to want to spend it three times. (Note well: This specific paragraph is not a criticism of Ocasio-Cortez's idea; it's a criticism of Congress in general.)
- dragonwriter 8y ago> She cites Lincoln and FDR as evidence that radical ideas can be good ones. But "there have been radical ideas that have been good" does not imply "this radical idea is a good one". But it does rebut the common line of argument that it is preemptively deployed against, which is “Radical ideas should be rejected as bad merely because they are radical.” > As for the idea itself: IIRC, there seem to be significant second-order effects that keep the federal government's income at 18-22% of GDP, no matter what the tax rates are. So raising the rates like this may provide significantly less new income than she expects. To the extent that revenue seems relatively stable with apparently large changes in rates, I don't think those are “second order effects”, I think that they are coordinated changes to tax policy other than rates. The US doesn't have some kind fof special sui generis immunity to policy changing effective rate of total taxation. Also, US federal tax revenues were 27.1% of GDP in 2017 [0], so the 18-22% range is not only not immutable, but also not what is recently observed. [0] https://www.oecd.org/tax/revenue-statistics-united-states.pdf https://www.oecd.org/tax/revenue-statistics-united-states.pd...
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoYour first part is fair, and your second part has actual data. I'm not sure why you're being downvoted. There might be some kind of gaussian distribution on good ideas, though. The more radical an idea, the lower probability that it's correct. It's still not zero, and the idea should be judged on the merits. But the further out the idea is, the more radical it is, it seems reasonable to say that the level of skepticism should go up.
- sp332 8y agoActually someone else called her radical. That quote was just her brush-off of the comment.