5 ms·
> The yacht is made of wood, metal, and plastic. Building it requires many thousands of hours of effort. Workers have to find the trees, cut them down, haul the
by airstrike 8y ago
> The yacht is made of wood, metal, and plastic. Building it requires many thousands of hours of effort. Workers have to find the trees, cut them down, haul the lumber across vast distances, cut it, sand it, polish it, paint it, etc., etc., etc. If you weren't commissioning the yacht, all of those materials and man-hours could be put to other, better uses. For all the good it does the Congolese people, you may as well pay them to build the yacht, then burn it before their eyes. Taking it through the window, into your own possession and for your own consumption, has the same effect.
Wow. A lot to unpack here. The author was doing just fine up until this paragraph.
What "other, better uses" does the author propose? Better yet, who defines what uses are better or worse? I'm sure those workers who chopped down the wood or built the yacht would much prefer I pay them than a different worker, even if I want to buy the yacht just to watch it burn.
The author fails to understand the fundamental principle of Utility[0]. It's intrinsically up to an individual to determine that which has utility for them.
> That's why wealth is toxic. As long as someone's money is tucked away in his bank account, we're safe. But the minute it starts to leak out, via consumption, we all become that much worse off.
What an outlandish claim. If consumption were to halt entirely, no money would exchange hands and we'd go back to fending for ourselves by foraging and hunting.
At some point, we have to stop listening to laymen. This is true of every field, but Economics for some reason seems to be the layman's favorite.
I'm not an Economist either, but at least I don't go around pontificating about things I know not to know.
––––––––––
⁰ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility
- pesmhey 8y agoI think the author falls into the 'it's better to have cake than to eat it' camp. Of course wealth in this case is toxic - you miss the point of it.
- airstrike 8y ago> Of course wealth in this case is toxic Says who? That is not an axiomatic truth. You'll need to provide evidence.
- pesmhey 8y ago>Definition of toxic (Entry 1 of 3) 1 : containing or being poisonous material especially when capable of causing death or serious debilitation toxic waste a toxic radioactive gas an insecticide highly toxic to birds 2 : exhibiting symptoms of infection or toxicosis the patient became toxic two days later 3 : extremely harsh, malicious, or harmful toxic sarcasm 4 : relating to or being an asset that has lost so much value that it cannot be sold on the market You can't eat cake that's gone bad because you've kept it in your cupboard too long. Even though we're using a metaphor here, literally - in the very definition of literal - if you don't eat your cake, it actually does become toxic, defeating the purpose of having it in the first place. edit: btw, I think we're in agreement. I'm advocating for thoughtful consumption.
- SilasX 8y agoSo, you're saying that the worst possible thing someone can do is produce but never consume?
- xenocratus 8y agoIsn't consumption essentially you letting someone else be on the producer side? I agree that for one entity it might be good to produce and not consume, but it makes no sense as a general statement. Production and consumption can only exist together. Sure, we have to put some thought into what we consume, but consumption in/by itself can't be "evil"
- pesmhey 8y agoTo follow the food analogy, I'm saying that you've gotta eat to have energy to be productive to make food to eat. In other words, you have to produce in order to consume in order to produce in order to consume, and so on. The worst possible thing would be consumption sans production - that's cancer. Can you think of examples where you would produce without consumption? I can't think of any. Even intellectual discoveries consume information. My answer to your question would be that it would be the most impossible thing someone could do to produce but never consume.
- SilasX 8y agoNeeding to consume is a complication from the core insight. If necessary, replace with someone who consumes at subsistence level. - Person A works X amount, and consumes typically. - Person B works X amount, and consumes at subsistence. Judging solely from the perspective of other people, which person is better to have? Or, for another example, the sun produces without (economically-relevant, purchased) consumption. What if someone were like the sun, and charged for sunlight, but never spent the money? They just left the money in the bank forever.
- pesmhey 8y agoBetween person A and B, the 'better' person to have would be the one who produces more valuable stuff. Better is a tricky way to talk about this though, because these two people might have different inherent capabilities. The most ideal answer would be that person A and person B should each find their ecological niche where their consumption and production of resources are in optimal balance. The 'better' person to have in this case would be the person most suited to your same niche. If your statement had been 'produces X amount', and not 'works X amount', then my answer definitely changes. Less consumption for the same amount of production is always better, because in aggregate it means more resources for consumption, and production goes up. Or maybe not? I'd be interested to think about a good counterpoint. Even the sun consumes - it consumes hydrogen, helium, lots of stuff. And that stuff is localized to the sun. Perhaps we'll figure out a way to add fuel from somewhere else to the sun one day, but as of right now, the sun consumes an ultimately limited amount of stuff. We have a pretty decent understanding now of the relationship between the sun's consumption and production of resources. If someone were like the sun, and charged for sunlight, then they would HAVE to spend the money on acquiring more hydrogen. If they left the money in the bank, then they wouldn't be able to produce the sunlight that earns them money.
- metabagel 8y ago"What "other, better uses" does the author propose? What "other, better uses" does the author propose?" Probably anything which constitutes a true necessity, such as food, clean water, shelter, sanitary conditions, etc.
- airstrike 8y agoWe better get off HN, then, because this ain't a true necessity.
- Matumio 8y agoYou seem to have forgotten "the window" in the argument, separating a single participant from "society" (aka the Congolese people). If you accept that you only care about "the Congolese people" then the author's conclusions make a lot of sense. Except that they don't quite work without the window, which removes the needs of a single participant from the society to be optimized. A general conclusion like "wealth is toxic" cannot be made without explaining why the window is still in place. I don't think it's spending that hurts society. What hurts is if a single person spends so much above average that it notably drains the number of workers still available to serve the needs of everyone else in that society.
- airstrike 8y ago> What hurts is if a single person spends so much above average that it notably drains the number of workers still available to serve the needs of everyone else in that society. While that could be true, we currently aren't really dealing with a shortage of doctors because there are too many people building yachts. If anything there are too many unskilled workers because our educational system has largely failed to adapt in the last 100 years.
- metabagel 8y ago"I'm sure those workers who chopped down the wood or built the yacht would much prefer I pay them than a different worker, even if I want to buy the yacht just to watch it burn." What the workers do or don't appreciate has nothing to do with the author's argument. A squad of mercenaries might appreciate you paying them to murder someone.
- cwkoss 8y agoI think people listen to laymen economists because the majority of celebrity economists espouse logically contradictory theories that support their financial patrons.
- airstrike 8y agoI think only misinformed, powerless people listen to laymen economists.
- fragsworth 8y agoI think you're missing something about Utility - specifically that ethically, if we're going to talk about this notion of utility, we should increase aggregate utility (the sum of utility of all people). The utility of money to a single individual decreases as the individual acquires more money, i.e. utility of money is higher for poor people and lower for rich people. This notion applies directly to the things purchased by that money. The aggregate utility (benefit to humanity) of a yacht that a single individual purchases is therefore far lower than the aggregate utility of a bunch of smaller things that are purchased by a bunch of less wealthy individuals. And then what follows from that is by purchasing yachts, you are promoting an industry that lowers aggregate utility. It can be argued that if you're going to "feel bad" about money, this spending is what is the potentially unethical part, which was the author's point.
- mattnewton 8y agoI think the author’s central point is that money can be viewed as an IOU for future utility from society. If I view all of society outside the individual as one agent, say a giant company that owns the stores you shop in and still employed you, and that company pays you $COMPANY-BUCKS to be redeemed at the company store, they got utilty out of you for nothing until you redeem the company bucks for something. The author is saying that accumulating wealth is just, assuming you were payed fairly, showing a debt society has taken on to you. Society hasn’t had to produce something in return yet. And it’s how you spend that debt that can cause problems, not that the debt exists. You can spend it in ways that direct people to create utility that you share with society or in ways that lock that utility up.