4 ms·
Switching from base 10 to base 12 makes a lot of sense
- Jabbles 16y agoNo it doesn't. For one thing, 12 doesn't have the factor 5. Who says having the factor of 3 is better? And the whole 10 fingers thing? That might be useful to keep. I assume the article wasn't meant to be taken literally, but it's hardly high-quality content, and I'm sure everyone who reads HN knows about non-decimal based systems.
- jgrahamc 16y agoThe point is that 12 has more factors than 10 making a lot of everyday calculations easier. Sure you lose dividing by 5, but you gain dividing by 3, 4 and 6. Also, you get nice decimals for common fractions. I assume the article wasn't meant to be taken literally I think it makes a lot of sense to use base-12 instead of base-10. Of course, it'll never happen because it'd be an almost impossible change given the weight of education and the metric system.
- mooism2 16y agoIt might have made sense to use base 12 in the first place, but it certainly doesn't make sense to switch from base 10 to base 12 now.
- alenlpeacock 16y ago3 is a more useful factor for many applications, including measurement for architecture, art, photography, etc. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_thirds http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_thirds If I had to rank factors that would be most useful for measurement, I'd put 2, 3, and 4, and even 8 above 5.
- wwortiz 16y agoFor the title you gave this on HN you sure to present very many reasons as to why it makes a lot of sense (other than more factors). I think probably the hardest part for me to learn to count and do math in base 12 would be to use and learn two new symbols to represent 10 and 11. By the way German also has separate words for eleven and twelve.
- jgrahamc 16y agoIn the book I mention the author uses three words for the current 10 and 11 and 12: dec, elf and zen. dec from Latin, elf from German and zen to recall that 12 is a dozen. The factors really are the key (since you get lots of easy divisions, a multiplication table that has lots of nice patterns, lots of simplified decimals). Then there's the relationship with 'natural' systems such as months in year, hours in a day etc.
- khafra 16y agoA few past civilizations seem to have hit on smooth numbers as their base, instead of the "digits" heuristic. I think both have their advantages.
- mooism2 16y agoSpanish has separate words up to fifteen. French has separate words up to sixteen. The linguistic argument for switching is suspect (even setting aside words such as "twenty" and "hundred").
- wwortiz 16y agoI don't know if I would consider 12 and 13 in Spanish separate, but yes it is suspect. I just posted because I was wondering if there were any real advantages to base 12, or some given examples.
- 1amzave 16y agoIf high school memories serve, Latin has regular number-names for 11 through 17, but then semi-irregular ones for 18 (duodeviginti, or "two from twenty") and 19 (undeviginti, "one from twenty"). (I say semi-irregular because they're inconsistent with 11 through 17, but at least consistent with each other, unlike say "eleven" and "twelve", as far as I can tell.)
- algorias 16y agoI find the argument of language favoring base-12 very weak. If a groundbreaking change like replacing base-10 with 12 (or anything else), language would also be able to evolve and adapt to it. Spanish has words up to fifteen, by the way.
- corin_ 16y agoNothing on the blog itself made me think jgc was making the argument that a switch would "make a lot of sense", just the title he used on HN (and his first comment in this thread). That struck me as slightly odd.
- petercooper 16y ago24 has 2 more factors and could be as easily represented by the alphabet minus 2 letters. A day has 24 hours, there are 24 major and minor keys, and English could be represented using 24 letters unifying both written language and numbers in a single system!
- alenlpeacock 16y agoI made a little dozenal/decimal online converter, check it out: http://flud.org/dozenal-calc.html http://flud.org/dozenal-calc.html
- drallison 16y agoHeinlein argued for base 60. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexagesimal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexagesimal