5 ms·
Why do you need an externally defined unique ID? If I tell you that i am Spooky23, 123 Main St, anytown, AK, spooky23@example.com, what more uniqueness do you
by Spooky23 8y ago
Why do you need an externally defined unique ID?
If I tell you that i am Spooky23, 123 Main St, anytown, AK, spooky23@example.com, what more uniqueness do you need?
Hoarding passport numbers, drivers licenses, ssn, etc usually doesn’t serve a legitimate purpose. When it is required to meet compliance or other requirements (say an payroll processor who needs an SSN to withhold taxes), it needs to be protected and have access controls.
Marriott does not have any need to authoritatively know who I am beyond payment arrangements. I'm not borrowing money from Marriott, so they don't need my SSN. They may need my passport when I check into an international hotel to meet compliance requirements, but they don't need to store it in a reservation system, and don't need to store it beyond the international jurisdiction where I checked in.
- ngneer 8y agoSpooky23 seems to be implicitly relying on uniqueness that is leveraged by the underlying message routing system. With the case of "123 Main St, anytown, AK" there is an implicit assumption that no one else lives at that address. With the case of "spooky23@example.com" there is an implicit assumption that the mailbox is not shared. Hoarding numbers serves the very purpose of ensuring a unique assignment. For instance, if "the" department of transportation did not have a "global" database, then it would risk minting the same number twice. That having been said, it is true that knowledge of a "master" identity is not a requirement for making payment arrangements.
- Spooky23 8y agoWhat’s the anticipated trust level? For most commerce, I need to be able to tell that you are the same “Spooky23” who was here last time. If you need to positively and authoritatively identify me, collecting numbers is not sufficient. End of the day, these companies are either overcollecting for convenience or doing a poor job of collecting information for compliance purposes.
- maccard 8y ago> End of the day, these companies are either overcollecting for convenience or doing a poor job of collecting information for compliance purposes. Or both. Overxollecting makes sense at a global level (all systems the same everywhere), but even if they only collect what they need they're clearly not treating it correctly
- cr0sh 8y agoMarriott probably keeps the passport numbers to identify people in their hotel chain management systems, because they are an international company with hotels (and other similar properties) worldwide. Name, address, and email probably isn't fine-grained enough, as multiple people can all share the same information - and name isn't enough because some people name all their kids the same, sometimes the same as the parents (yes, it is crazy insane, perhaps narcissistic - but people). Then there are those who do similar things for fraudulent reasons. In theory (I'm sure there are ways around it) no two people should have the same passport and passport ID number. Now, not everyone has a passport, but if they do, and they are travelling internationally, Marriott likely would rather have that information, so they can track you as you use their services in multiple places around the world (and offer you various amenities, upgrades, advertising, etc of course)... That would be my guess.
- maccard 8y agoPresumably a combination of name and email address is enough for "marketing" purposes for Marriott. Less nefariously*, I did a bit of digging and in the UK, hotels are required to record an ID for aliens (ironically, there is no central ID system in the UK, which I assume is why it's for aliens only). If the liability is on the hotel in case of incorrect information, it makes sense they would require the most common form of internationally recognized ID (a passport).Italy has a similar system introduced in the 30's by the fascist govt at the time for keeping track of who was where when. If I were an international business,it would make sense to me to comply with the regulations everywhere rather than try selectively enforce it. (Nefarious-ness of Marriott. Not necessarily a comment on trusting the people who came up with the law in the first place)
- elliekelly 8y agoMany countries legally require hotels to record guest passports.
- mulmen 8y agoMy response was to the idea that unique identifiers are only useful for debt collection. In response to your moved goalposts: how is storing the passport ID different from storing the address or email? Are all three not "externally defined unique IDs"?
- nly 8y agoI'd rather hotels had my passport number than most home address.