3 ms·
That’s not the answer either. You’ll not get the most able or most willing politicians but only the cleanest or anodyne candidates who may not be the ablest ca
by mc32 8y ago
That’s not the answer either. You’ll not get the most able or most willing politicians but only the cleanest or anodyne candidates who may not be the ablest candidates. It’s a terrible filter.
- perfmode 8y agoWe already don’t get the most able politicians. We get corrupt and self-interested ones en masse. This argument is strong in theory, but not so much in practice.
- geofft 8y agoBut we're making steps towards not doing so. Why give up? This is like arguing for monarchy because democracy is a huge amount of time/effort and is imperfect anyway so why not save time. I've heard many bad arguments for monarchism as it happens, but none are quite so bad as "Why bother even trying to have good government?"
- perfmode 8y agoAccountability is precisely how we are making progress.
- newsgremlin 8y agoIn the UK there are people who would seriously argue for just that, because the image of the monarchy is one of prestige, superiority and good public relation. In other words good PR that politicians dream of, having a (apparently) off hands approach to politics also helps. I believe that shows the popularity and image contest of democratic politics.
- 794CD01 8y agoIt's very difficult to keep your digital record clean your entire life. Anyone who manages it is either very able and motivated or Amish.
- newsgremlin 8y agoThese days when someone talks about a "capable" politician, I can (and probably most others with little hope left) only think of how they have perfected the skill and art of lying and deception, rather than the judicial, diplomatic, and relational skills that they are intended to strive for.