4 ms·
> Economically we are far better off with children in care and parents in the work force but this may not pay off in the long term if future generations fail to
by ryandrake 8y ago
> Economically we are far better off with children in care and parents in the work force but this may not pay off in the long term if future generations fail to perform in life.
Who is "we" in this statement? The parents? Society? I think whether it makes sense varies from family to family. When my daughter was born, my wife and I did the math and it made zero sense for her to go back to work and for us to pay for child care. The cost of child care was far more than she could possibly bring home. Plus, we have the (apparently old fashioned) belief that an attentive and caring parent would do a better job raising her than some rando child care worker who's trying to corral 10 other kids all day.
- xupybd 8y agoSorry, that point has generated more heat than I expected. What I was meaning here (and said poorly) is that for society specialisation seems to work out with a net overall increase in productivity. If some specialise in childcare it should free others up to specialise in other fields and allow those specialised in childcare to look after more children than stay at home parents would. I also should have stated that this is an assumption I was basing my next statements on, not a statement of fact. This was also just a generalisation used to reason from. I'm not trying to speak for anyone's individual situation. I share your belief that a caring parent is going to be better at raising children than a care worker. I would choose this option myself if I were to have children regardless of the economics (here in New Zealand childcare is heavily subsidised by the government, so the numbers would be a little different).
- PaulHoule 8y agoIf you work outside the home and put your kids in child care you pay taxes and help billionaires get rich, two things you don't do if you take care of your own. 20 years ago there was a comic in Z magazine that showed two day care workers talking about how paradoxical it was that they couldn't afford to put their own kids in day care. Of course they blamed "capitalism" but in other industries "capitalism" works differently. What was revolutionary about the Ford motor car was that auto workers were productive enough that they could afford the cars that they made, not something that is true about childcare workers. Some kids are in family situations that are worse than the average day care. For instance, I know a lady who raised a crop of five children, four of which were spectacularly unsuccessful, and then she took care of their children, most of whom turned out to be white people with black problems. Somebody might look at this situation and see "love", but that love is obviously toxic. In the case of our family we had our son in day care part time, which gave my wife a break sometimes and let him get some socialization, but didn't have a huge cost. As he spent most of his time growing up with adults he wound up with great verbal skills.