3 ms·
I would like to release some OpenSource projects. But I don't want it to be used for evil. I understand, and share, your sentiment. But really, once you put co
by mindcrime 8y ago
I would like to release some OpenSource projects. But I don't want it to be used for evil.
I understand, and share, your sentiment. But really, once you put code out there, you can never know who's using it, what they're using it for, and whether or not they would respect your license terms. I mean, if the NSA find your software useful for something, do you really think they're going to skip using it because your license says they can't? Or what about the North Korean government, or the Russian mafia, etc. Criminals / terrorists / nation-state governments / etc. are probably a much larger source of evil-doing than a handful of corporations, and none of those entities are likely to care about a software license.
Personally, I'd go for just using whatever normal F/OSS license you'd otherwise pick, and in the README just add a note saying "I'm asking nicely that you please not use this software for evil purposes". It has no real legal effect, but, as noted above, having it in the license really doesn't help a whole lot anyway. And you still make your position clear this way.
What you probably need to ask yourself is "on balance, is me releasing this software going to make the world a better place, or a worse places". If the answer is the former, I'd encourage you to just do it.
- eesmith 8y agoI think the viewpoint is not "do you really think they're going to skip using it" but rather a desire to not implicitly condone its use for evil. Back to the topic, the graph isomorphism program "nauty" had such a license. http://users.cecs.anu.edu.au/~bdm/nauty/COPYRIGHT.txt http://users.cecs.anu.edu.au/~bdm/nauty/COPYRIGHT.txt says: > Earlier (pre-2.6) versions of this package carried a different notice: "Permission is hereby given for use and/or distribution with the exception of sale for profit or application with nontrivial military significance." These days most people use nauty via a larger package such as Magma, Sage, or GAP, and often they don't even know they are using nauty. Due to the legal nonsense that large package distributors need to worry about, it has proved too much trouble to maintain an idiosyncratic licence. I didn't change my opinion about military use, but it is no longer part of the formal notice. Brendan McKay (Jan 20, 2016)