3 ms·
The Forgotten Philosopher
- michael_dorfman 19y agoJohn Stuart Mill is forgotten? From the headline, I thought they were going to pull up one of the more obscure German Idealists (along the lines of Gellner's joke: "There are three great German philosophers: Hegel, Schlegel, and Bagel. No one understands Hegel. No one has read Schlegel. And Bagel doesn't exist. Or as the Bagelians like to put it: Non-existence is the essence of his Being.")
- aspirant 18y agoBut shouldn't we judge a work of political philosophy by how long it continues to inspire debate? Probably not. If well reasoned people are debating, wouldn't we judge the philosophy by its ability to end the debate? People who are poorly reasoned will be able to debate even rubbish endlessly.