7 ms·
Can someone explain to me why an investor would want to invest in a foreign debt and currency from a country that has capital controls and a history of underval
by cm2187 8y ago
Can someone explain to me why an investor would want to invest in a foreign debt and currency from a country that has capital controls and a history of undervaluing its currency?
- pstrateman 8y agoInvestors with other peoples money receiving fees based on annual return. What do they care about the risks?
- coughupalung 8y agoAny reputable investment firm will have risk management reports. If you don't like your fund pouring significant money into A+ rate bonds of a country with potential headwinds then pull out or sue.
- hermitdev 8y ago> What do they care about the risks? Plenty. You dont last long in finance if you take outsized risks and lose your clients money. Various firms and investors have varying risk tolerances, but any finance firm worth anything has a risk team that is daily monitoring these things.
- codycraven 8y agoLike garbage mortgages? While I'd really like to believe companies will act appropriately for their own long-term success, in reality the people working there look out for themselves and are just a job hop away from a fresh start at a different finance company. I see this in tech all the time where developers at agencies pound out horrible code with no long-term care for what they deliver, just that they meet the request in the here and now.
- projectramo 8y agoThey might do it for 3x the return: "China’s government bonds were among the world’s best performers in 2018, returning 7.7 percent, while U.S. Treasuries earned 0.8 percent, ICE Bank of America Merrill Lynch data show. That gain is in yuan terms, however, and the yuan dropped 5.4 percent against the U.S. dollar." So 7.7 - 5.4 = 2.3% which is almost 3x 0.8% return on US Treasuries.
- anonymfus 8y ago>So 7.7 - 5.4 = 2.3% Seriously? 0.946 * 1.077 = 1.018842 So about 1.9% which is about 2.4x 0.8% return on US Treasuries.
- nly 8y agoAnd shaved both ways in the forex market
- seppin 8y ago3x given the risk involved? Not worth it
- pkaye 8y agoThat is not how you would do that math though. You have to multiply the percentages. (1+0.077)*(1-0.054)=1.0188 => 1.88%
- leptoniscool 8y agoAs I understand it, when goods are trades the opposite sides each accumulates the others foreign currency. They can use this currency to buy things in the other's country, in this case their debt.
- kissickas 8y agoA possibility is that they believe that country no longer has much to gain from undervaluing its currency as its neighbors are starting to be real competitors in manufacturing, and now they're more interested in building up a consumer class.
- ianhawes 8y agoThis. China is transitioning quickly to a consumer based economy from manufacturing.
- doctorpangloss 8y agoOn the contrary, the market is signaling that Chinese consumers are reducing their spending, choosing to save even more. > [These sales] will help finance the deficits without running up a dangerous amount of debt in foreign currency. That's why they're selling! The arbitrage, really, is that sales of this nature are very technical and not well understood by consumers. They signal bear market like a yield curve inversion does. But because it's so technical, the average person's confidence isn't impacted the same way that a headline, "China is Hunting for Foreign Buyers of its Empty Apartments" would. Even though both have similar macroeconomic effects, given enough scale.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- scoot_718 8y agoThe idea that Chinese citizens save most of their income has been wrong for about a decade. They're carrying a lot of private debt.
- AlexCoventry 8y ago> sales of this nature... signal bear market like a yield curve inversion does How? How is this different from the treasuries the US sells every year?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 8y agoYou give someone a billion dollars, and they promise to give you back your billion plus another 210 million three years later. Probably wouldn't want to put your only billion there, but if you had say 160 billion sitting around, put one there and the other 159 billion in US treasuries you have added 30 basis points of upside to your return at a risk of 29 basis points.
- unioncalia 8y agoI wouldn't invest in foreign debt where I can't even safely go to that country and contest! => Thirteen Canadians have been detained in China since Huawei executive’s arrest, says Ottawa https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-thirteen-canadians-detained-in-china-since-huawei-executives-arrest/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-thirteen-ca...
- ianai 8y agoThis and related thoughts lead me to wonder whether China may soon face a Greece like meltdown. They’ve established themselves as bad trade actors.
- jazzyjackson 8y agoGiven that the UK & USA has a habit of showing up with a Navy when someone refuses to trade (thinking of the perry expedition, the opium wars) I'm left wondering what a good trade actor looks like.
- aristophenes 8y agoIs your claim that good trade is not possible? I think in the 150 years since your examples there have been many positive examples of trade beneficial to both parties, and hardly any that are harmful, though there should be a handful. For example, South Koreas economy, in a single persons lifetime, has grown 60x per person, inflation adjusted. An entire nation pulled out of poverty. https://tradingeconomics.com/south-korea/gdp-constant-prices https://tradingeconomics.com/south-korea/gdp-constant-prices You can see that trade is a major part of their economy, currently around 80%: https://tradingeconomics.com/south-korea/trade-percent-of-gdp-wb-data.html https://tradingeconomics.com/south-korea/trade-percent-of-gd... You can look at their neighbor North Korea for a counter example, that has established hostile relations with most other countries and has a juche philosophy that frowns on trade.
- jazzyjackson 8y ago
- jganetsk 8y agoThey undervalue their currency by pinning it to the dollar. So investing in RMB is equivalent, in terms of risk, to investing in the USD. And there's plenty of demand for investing in USD.
- microdrum 8y agoInteresting line re: this from last year's moviee Crazy Rich Asians: "There is a Hokkien phrase, 'Gar gee nang.' It means, our own kind of people. And you're not our own kind." "Because I'm not rich? 'Cause I didn't go to a British boarding school, or I wasn't born into a wealthy family?" "You're a foreigner. American. And all Americans think about is their own happiness. "Don't you want Nick to be happy?" "It's an illusion. We understand how to build things that last. Something you know nothing about." Funny thing is that I feel like it is indeed rare for cultures-countries to think about building things that last. But the US is actually one of the few countries that does---whereas China can't float this level of debt at attractive rates because it is NOT long term focused. It keeps doing insane, credibility-destroying things. Yet always talks about how it is a long term actor.
- Stryder 8y agoDouble-standard is the oldest trick in the book for establishing and maintaining power dynamics.
- microdrum 8y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18821202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18821202
- jhwang5 8y agoWay to get cultural insights into China from a Hollywood movie bro
- krapp 8y agoTo be fair, it's a Hollywood movie based on a book written by a Chinese author based on his childhood in Singapore. So not entirely without legitimate cultural insight.
- jhwang5 8y agoIt's written for the western audience. And I think you just made my point for me. At best it reflects the rich Chinese people's attitude - since when is HN rampant with small sample generalizations?
- acchow 8y agoIn short - almost everything has a clearing price.
- _cs2017_ 8y agoCapital controls don't apply, you buy the bonds through HK. Devaluation is always a risk, in any country. USD can fall too, look at historical USD exchange rates to the world currency basket. Foreign bond investors have to live with that risk; I assume they don't expect a large Yuan devaluation. also see https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-11-16/the-world-s-biggest-bond-rally-is-picking-up-steam-in-china https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-11-16/the-world...