3 ms·
Nobody is watching a movie because Jim Gaffer designed the lighting rigs, yet Jim Gaffer is protected by a union and Joe Programmer is not. You don't have to b
by chongli 8y ago
Nobody is watching a movie because Jim Gaffer designed the lighting rigs, yet Jim Gaffer is protected by a union and Joe Programmer is not.
You don't have to be a star in order to collectively bargain, you just need to organize with your colleagues.
- cheeze 8y agoYeah, but framing this as an issue in the gaming industry is disingenuous. A lack of unionization is a problem in programming in general, not just video games.
- chongli 8y agoYes that's true, although sometimes it seems like game programmers are exploited due to their passion for video games.
- EpicEng 8y agoThere's definitely exploitation, but it's also market forces at play. When you have a never ending stream of devs who can't wait to work for you, well, you don't have to pay as much.
- eterm 8y agoThere's a never ending stream of aspiring actors and writers too. Forming a union has offered them some protection from being exploited by studios and perhaps game developers should do the same.
- zozbot123 8y ago> Forming a union has offered them some protection from being exploited by studios If the Weinstein scandal is any indication, no it hasn't. Unions are not without their problems, while more widespread awareness about the actual working conditions in any given industry (be it acting or game development) is highly effective, one way or the other. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.
- EpicEng 8y agoAnd most of them aren't getting jobs. Software development and acting are barely comparable professions. The average programmer is far better off than the average actor, even with their Union
- pcwalton 8y agoElectricians earn more than janitors do. But the existence of service workers' unions doesn't make the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers any less legitimate.
- ABCLAW 8y agoActors and Actresses don't face issues getting roles on the basis that they've been priced out of the market. Issues in getting jobs have to do with the limited supply of capitalized projects, high project transactional costs (including fairly high financial, equipment and professional costs), restrictions upon actor country of origin on the basis of bilateral entertainment tax treaties and a number of other structural issues. All of these issues mean that there's a substantial amount of activation energy required to get an entertainment product off the ground, which limits the amount of product projects in motion at any given time. Feel free to look up the various guild pay grades. The minimums are very low, and they're designed to prevent the 'be in this motion picture for free for exposure' race to the bottom, not to price small projects out of the market.
- shanghaiaway 8y agoTop writers don't negotiate through unions, they have agents.
- watwut 8y agoProgrammers in general are treated waaay better then game programmers. Specifically, programmer can have 40 hours week, bigger salary then game programmer and (subjectively) reasonably interesting work "at a same time". It takes some fighting and searching to get all three, the last seeming most hard. But it is possible and not really hard.
- cageface 8y agoI am not at all opposed to unions in principle but I'm not sure unionizing would be good for us. For skilled, high-demand labor like coding there are a lot of downsides to unions. Corruption, bureaucracy, union fees, increased regulation etc.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoNo, Unions are not the issue here. Collective bargaining would not yield Tom Cruise-like returns or even exceptional returns. The reason is that devs are ultimately a commodity. Actors, by the way - even good ones - are even more of a commodity. There are tons of spectacular actors who would work cheap. What brings in the audience is not the quality of the acting, it's the familiarity of the person, or the 'living brand'. The 'human being Tom Cruise' obviously has the most amazing, unbreakable IP protection on the 'brand Tom Cruise'. And it's the 'brand Tom Cruise' that has value. (And He only has to be a decent actor, not a even a great one) Unions might help with some things ... but generally that's not going to be it. The other thing to consider is the hugely risky and hit-driven nature of the business. Any 'investor' in games is risking so much, that the returns may be a little biased. Consider that even for a game that 'made a lot of money' - it still may not be rational to have invested in that game! It still maybe overall a 'bad investment' to invest in such things.
- chongli 8y agoI don't see AAA video games as inherently more risky than big budget films. I also don't think you have to reach Tom Cruise levels of success to be better off than a game developer. A union could do a lot for those who work in the game industry. Game developers work such insane hours during crunch time when there's really no need for it. With a union mandating a standard work week, the onus would be put on the producers of the game to plan effectively in order to meet a deadline. Game producers would have us all believe that games are uniquely complicated in a way that sets them apart from films and requires such ridiculous time commitments. That's rubbish. The vast majority of the work that goes into a triple A game is asset creation (graphics and sound). This makes games extremely similar to films which are dominated by CG and post-production work these days.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThat's a good point. Though I don't know if I'm sure about the risk, it would be good to see some data on that. Some games, especially follow ons of well established 'game brands' I can see as being less risky ... but for new titles? But yes, there's no reason for the countless hours, that's basically just taking advantage of creatives no doubt and admittedly unions may help in some way.