4 ms·
Amusingly "not lisp" is a feature on their comparison matrix.
by ZeroGravitas 16y ago
Amusingly "not lisp" is a feature on their comparison matrix.
- runT1ME 16y agobhahaha. came to post that. I laughed out loud.
- kleiba 16y agoAt least they're honest enough to admit deficiencies. :-)
- mahmud 16y agoI found it a subtle admission of fault, because: 1) It's impossible for people who know Lisp to design a language that isn't Lisp(y). 2) You can't be a serious language designer without knowing Lisp, well. Because of #1 and #2, the author wants to align himself with the amateur school of successful language design (the people responsible for most stuff that comes pre-installed in your Redhat box.) and distances himself from egg-heads and language purists, and their potential criticism.
- alextgordon 16y ago1) It's impossible for people who know Lisp to design a language that isn't Lisp(y). 2) You can't be a serious language designer without knowing Lisp, well. Judging by the number of great languages that are not at all lispy, at least one of these is false.
- mahmud 16y agoConcrete instances please! :-) I specifically said "amateur school of successful language design". "Great" is subjective, but nearly all ground-breaking languages invented after Lisp are all Lisp-like (don't look at syntax.) Industrial, imperative languages are nearly always "designed" on a whim. They're all incremental improvements over Algol, and they're probably what you're talking about if you're of the great majority of the programmers. As of late, they're more Lispy than you can imagine. Except for a specific school of Lex & Yacc languages out of New Jersey, the great majority of professionally designed languages (i.e. by people with an appreciation for formal language design and semantics) have been Lispy and functional; characterized by clean minimal core, well specified semantics, even proven, and self-hosted implementation. Just to throw the discussion a bone and offer some perspective; I consider ActionScript 3 "Lispy", but not AWK or C++.
- silentbicycle 16y agoHow about K? It's a functional, "clean minimal core" APL with ragged arrays and lambdas. Lisp-influenced, but much less Lispy than one would expect if it's "impossible for people who know Lisp to design a language that isn't Lisp(y)". "I much preferred implementing and coding in LISP (sic), but once I was dealing with big data sets and then having to do fairly simple calculations, APL just seemed to have the better vocabulary." - Arthur Whitney (http://cacm.acm.org/opinion/interviews/26246-a-conversation-with-arthur-whitney/fulltext http://cacm.acm.org/opinion/interviews/26246-a-conversation-...)
- mahmud 16y agoYou just supported my arguments, silentbicycle; it's "much less Lispy" but not "orthogonal to Lisp". Small, expression based, self-hosting, declarative, has a core-data structure it uses to represent most of its input .. APL, Forth, and Smalltalk might not be proper functional programming languages, but they're of the same "spirit". Now compare this to something horribly broken, like Basic ..
- silentbicycle 16y agoI suspected as much. "Lispiness" is a fuzzy concept, though - Lua is Lispier than Python, but is Tcl more or less Lispy than SML? Etc. K is probably the least Lispy language I can think of with that pedigree. Joy may be another exception, but it's mainly an experimental / research language.
- mahmud 16y agoTcl shouldn't be compared to SML; ML is a triumph of human achievement. See Alice: http://www.ps.uni-saarland.de/alice/ http://www.ps.uni-saarland.de/alice/ Some Lisps are more Lisp than others; compare Dylan to Emacs Lisp. Dylan has that refined taste, that well-thought out essence, even if it's an infix, algolish language in apperance. While elisp is an orthodox Lisp, in every sense, and is unpalatable because of its true-to-form "Lispiness". There are languages that are semantically consistent, and that's probably what I meant by "Lispy". Then there are languages which are nothing but compiler hacks; you can tell whoever dreamed them up "grew" this hairball by tweaking a parser until it did something he wanted.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]