6 ms·
Once this stuff stabilizes a bit, games wrapped up as progressive web apps might become a thing. Could be an interesting way to get distribution outside of the
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
Once this stuff stabilizes a bit, games wrapped up as progressive web apps might become a thing. Could be an interesting way to get distribution outside of the app stores via regular search engines for a lot of indie developers using e.g. unity. Also a nice way for mainstream game developers to show of demos without requiring cumbersome installations, lengthy detours via some app store, etc.
- meritt 8y agoI hope you're right. We've had this capability for quite some time but for some reason it never takes off. Bastion released a version for Chrome's native client 7 years ago, the game ran amazingly well, but that version of the game doesn't seem to exist anymore. NaCl was shut down in favor of webassembly so here's hoping. [1] https://kotaku.com/5866594/you-can-now-play-bastion-in-googles-chrome-web-browser https://kotaku.com/5866594/you-can-now-play-bastion-in-googl... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvKEomoiKBA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvKEomoiKBA
- styfle 8y agoNaCl was not cross platform and not standardized the same way that Web Assembly is.
- badsectoracula 8y agoOn the other hand i hope he's wrong because that means games can die at the whim of whoever hosts the servers (they already have tons of issues with DRM and such). Personally i prefer to have control over when and where the games (and other software) i have are installed and i prefer to buy games from GOG and other DRM-free places (that give me an offline installer i can place on my external hard drive) whenever possible, but comparing the popularity between GOG and Steam with developers and publishers tells me that if the option for them to take even more control away from the consumers is there, the vast majority of them will go full on it. This loss of control over the software i use is my main annoyance by far as a user when it comes to the trend of pushing everything as a web app.
- meritt 8y agoOh, I completely agree with your sentiment but I don't think that means it has to be hosted remotely. No reason you shouldn't be able to download a packaged web binary to run locally. I wonder if webassembly supports that notion or not?
- krapp 8y ago>I wonder if webassembly supports that notion or not? It does[0]. It's just a spec for a bytecode, and it's designed with the intent of being run in the browser and natively. [0]https://webassembly.org/docs/non-web/ https://webassembly.org/docs/non-web/
- badsectoracula 8y agoThere isn't really a reason to offer a game as a web application if the goal isn't to have it run inside the web browser though. As i wrote in the other reply, i'm not worried about the best thing to do that is technically possible with the method, but what is the most likely to happen (assuming publishing games as web applications take off in the first place, of course).
- erikpukinskis 8y agoWeb applications can be packaged for offline use. It’d be cool if browsers let you back up local copies of sites though.
- macspoofing 8y agoIsn't the problem with browser gaming the size of game assets? Any sizable game with sound and high-res textures could easily span multiple gigabytes (AAA games now approach 100 GB in size). The browser would have to enable persistent store at that scale to make that kind of gaming feasible. The alternative is server-rendering+streaming, but this doesn't need WebAssembly.
- krapp 8y agoOne problem is the paradigm of the browser and the expectations behind it. Websites are intended to load in a second, or at worse, a few seconds, so waiting any longer for an entire application would be excruciating. But no one minds downloading a multi-megabyte or gigabyte game over Steam or console, because users are trained to expect that to take a while. So what's needed, in my mind, is something with a user experience between the two - for games and applications to run in something more akin to a "package manager" mode than a basic browser window. Or maybe, on the web, have some alternative content to distract the user while the content downloads. The size of the entire download could possibly be reduced by having browsers ship with some standard plugins and modules, maybe runtimes (imagine having most of the Unity framework already in the browser.)
- plushpuffin 8y agoThis is the 90s all over again! Something very like this once existed for Java games. It was called Castanet. IIRC, the website ClassicGames.com (later acquired by Yahoo) used this before broadband really took off. http://mindprod.com/jgloss/castanet.html http://mindprod.com/jgloss/castanet.html
- ori_b 8y ago> So what's needed, in my mind, is something with a user experience between the two - for games and applications to run in something more akin to a "package manager" mode than a basic browser window. Maybe, just maybe, they could not run in a browser window.
- 8y ago
- roland-s 8y agoI think the problem is that nobody wants to go manually find games across the web, then maintain a bookmark list of their games, share purchasing info with 100 different sites, throw away a central liaison for customer support/community/developer interaction. Centralized repositories are way more useful and convenient and manageable. Now you could still do a central repo of webasm games but if anything I could see Steam offering a WebAssembly portal or something.
- da_chicken 8y agoThis makes me wonder what all the video streaming sites are thinking. I've got Amazon Prime and NetFlix and I stauchly refuse to add anything to that because it's too inconvenient. Then again, they're consolidating faster than the T-1000 in the foundry.
- roland-s 8y agoI had the same gripes, I use justwatch.com to search for a movie and see what streaming platforms offer it. Roku global search also does the same thing.
- wbl 8y agoI remember the glory days of flash games. Miniclip.com had some fun ones, and there were a bunch of sites.
- roland-s 8y agoNewgrounds.com, addictinggames.com, and kongregate.com are the three I remember. RIP Flash and Shockwave
- calibas 8y agoI believe you can just wrap it in something like Electron and then upload the whole package to services like Steam.
- taneq 8y ago
- cdoxsey 8y agoThe history of the web is one of centralization not decentralization. Steam is already a very good solution for distributing PC games and it has the added benefit of implementing a payment model, DLC features, social capabilities, updates, cloud-synchronized saved games, and, perhaps most importantly, a discovery service for finding new games. It even supports automatic WINE mode for windows-only games in linux (a feature that surprised me). I welcome the day when more games run automatically in OSX or Linux, but I think the need for an app platform isn't going to go away. And as someone who plays games often offline (on a plane or sometimes the train) it's really nice to not require an internet connection to play something.
- nikkwong 8y agoSure, but.. it does require downloading steam, which is a huge barrier to entry. As someone who's not a gamer, I've never downloaded Steam, which bars me from being exposed to all of it's content. That barrier also probably prohibits non-gamers such as myself from becoming ultra casual gamers. I'm sure the content is incredible, and I'd probably find it addicting. But heck, I can't be bothered into downloading steam. I'd be interested to see how landing on a webpage with a game ready-to-go turns non-gamers such as myself into infrequent or even frequent gamers. I would also argue that the ubiquity of the web is what makes games like agar.io and slither.io so popular, especially for kids. I remember being at techshop in SF and seeing kids rushing straight to their computers after school and opening slither.io and playing instantly. No friction. I'm sure that lends to their success. The web is great!
- pfisch 8y agoYou land on the webpage. Now enter all your payment info, validate purchase, make account. Cool Or is it f2p? So you land on page, still need to make an account for persistence. Also will need to do credit card eventually for game developer to make money. Also now game developer is looking at cdn costs of over 500 a month at a minimum for any kind of real game that is even 0.5 gb in size. I actually own a web assembly f2p game like this. It is really not a bright future for games that compete with real client games on steam that are not tiny and have the barest performance requirements. With unity basically the entire game needs to fit in like ~512 mb of ram, and runs poorly.