4 ms·
Making children work in sweatshops was legal... up until it wasn't. May I assume that every corporation and individual was obligated to work children in sweatsh
by falcolas 8y ago
Making children work in sweatshops was legal... up until it wasn't. May I assume that every corporation and individual was obligated to work children in sweatshops up until it was made illegal?
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThat's what happened, manufacturers who didn't use sweatshops couldn't offer the same low prices, and consumers went for the cheapest option.
- manigandham 8y agoThis isn't the same thing. Also nothing is that simple. The government is the people and the laws tend to reflect what they feel is acceptable because otherwise it would already be made illegal. Corporations are also these very same people and so they'll follow the same standards. I believe your issue has nothing to do with corporations but more about different cultures and values, and perhaps the efficiency of a government that can keep pace with the population.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y ago>This isn't the same thing. Where is the difference that would allow us to condemn the companies for maximizing profits by use labor laws but not condemn them for maximizing profits using tax laws? >Also nothing is that simple. Yet the previous statement seemed to have been made quite simply, an idea that if you take advantage of any law in your favor, you cannot condemn someone who takes advantage of any other law in their favor.
- fixermark 8y ago> Where is the difference that would allow us to condemn the companies for maximizing profits by use labor laws but not condemn them for maximizing profits using tax laws? Money isn't people.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoTax budgets have a direct effect on people, and for people who have to work for a living, while it appears to be taking money, it is equivalently taking their time, a fraction of their life.
- fixermark 8y agoThere's an analogy, but it's a weak one. Again, money isn't people. Abusing labor laws gets people killed directly. Failure of a government to collect enough tax can get people harmed or killed indirectly, but it's the government's responsibility to set tax policy, not a corporation's.
- jakelazaroff 8y agoIt's also the government's responsibility to set labor laws, but this doesn't absolve companies for mistreating their workers.
- fixermark 8y agoIt is a company's responsibility to follow laws. It is not, however, a company's responsibility to build highways, or to figure out how to finance the building of said highways, or to set up and fund public education, or to hire and pay police, is the point. When it becomes a company's responsibility to do so, we march gleefully into one of several dystopian cyberpunk science fictions (pick your favorite) ;)
- falcolas 8y agoCompanies, however, do take full advantage of the infrastructure built by the government using tax dollars, both directly and indirectly. For example, Google takes advantage of government contracts and grants, paid for by taxes. They also take advantage of the highway, city, water, power, education, housing, copyright and trademark laws, unemployment insurance, and legal (that is, the court system) infrastructure largely built and paid for (directly, by grants, or subsidies) using taxes.
- simplify 8y ago> Yet the previous statement seemed to have been made quite simply Exactly; OP makes a simple, matter-of-fact statement, and then proceeds to say "nothing is that simple" when they get challenged? Seems like a double standard to me.
- manigandham 8y agoNobody said anything about being allowed to condemn them. You are free to do so. The difference beyond people vs money is that a company with shareholders is not obligated to use child labor but is obligated to reduce tax expenditures. It's not simple because what do you consider more ethical? Tax minimization or hiring children to increase profits?
- telchar 8y agoThey're certainly not obligated to reduce tax expenditures. This is the commonly repeated falsehood that the fiduciary duty of a company to its shareholders obligates them to do anything and everything within the law to maximize profit - but that's incorrect. The fiduciary duty is much broader and can be respected while not blindly maximizing profit.
- manigandham 8y agoSure best interests can cover a lot. However, using a well-known tax strategy that has its own name, is completely legal, has no risk, and can save billions for a multinational company worth over half a trillion is a sound business decision. Not doing so would definitely be against the interests of the company.