4 ms·
I've always been surprised none of the "teachers" participating threatened to call the police. (I would probably have gotten arrested for assaulting the experi
by rdl 16y ago
I've always been surprised none of the "teachers" participating threatened to call the police. (I would probably have gotten arrested for assaulting the experimenter, myself.) I would expect the vast majority to comply or politely leave, but I would expect a few percent of people to have a past association with torture or abuse and thus to respond directly.
- masklinn 16y ago> I would probably have gotten arrested for assaulting the experimenter, myself You keep thinking that, if it can make you feel better about yourself. > I would expect the vast majority to comply or politely leave That's the point: it's not the case in any way, shape or form.
- tomjen3 16y agoActually if you know about the experiment, chances are that you won't comply.
- apl 16y agoThat's trivially true.
- tomjen3 16y agoSure, but you are also less likely to comply with similar requests outside the experiment.
- gruseom 16y agoThis actually could be studied empirically. I wonder if any work has been done on it. (I'd like to believe it's true, but I fear human nature isn't quite so responsive.)
- apl 16y agoNo, you aren't. Unfortunately, I must say. All those years taking Social Psychology courses haven't even made me immune to fascism! Seriously, though, reading some essential papers in the area is absolutely worthwhile. Replications of Milgram's initial experiments have investigated exactly this issue. Knowing that you're susceptible to manipulation by authority figures doesn't make you any less susceptible.
- apl 16y agoI've always been surprised none of the "teachers" participating threatened to call the police. (I would probably have gotten arrested for assaulting the experimenter, myself.) You and 99% of all people hearing about the Milgram experiments. The essential point, however, is that in fact you wouldn't. Just like 80% of all people state they'd DEFINITELY have been in the resistance during Third Reich. It's convenient to say that, but statistics tell us otherwise.
- rdl 16y agoFor me it is a lot more specific. I wouldn't have a big problem with enhanced interrogation in some contexts (I think torture is a bad policy and a losing strategy for a country, but in a classified interrogation context, wouldn't rock the boat). I have certainly been around recreational bdsm scenes which were fairly intense as well. I just don't trust doctors (psychologists, MDs) to be competent -- I have seen too many fuckups. Plus, there would be little personal risk in standing up to them. In the ww2 context, I am kind of ashamed to say I would have been an amoral defense contractor, doing whatever made me the most money with access to the best technical challenges and toys. I wouldn't have been initially willing to start off with war crimes, but I could definitely see using slave labor, overlooking virtually any other crimes, to ship, especially if it seemed like losing could lose the war. Or, if not a defense industrialist, a soldier.