3 ms·
This is a common conflation of intelligence evaluation criteria which is discussed in detail in Jose Hernandez-Orallo's 2017 book Measure of all minds. It can
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
This is a common conflation of intelligence evaluation criteria which is discussed in detail in Jose Hernandez-Orallo's 2017 book Measure of all minds.
It can be simultaneously true that we cannot describe in a causally deterministic way how a system works while also determining with some confidence that the system is performing as desired. This is true of all human systems.
So if you don't know how people drive, but have enough confidence to let them drive based on performance in evaluation scenarios, then similarly we should be able to let machines drive assuming they perform equally as well as humans over the same contexts without knowing how they drive either.
- ddingus 8y agoNot until they can demonstrate agency.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoDo you want machines to have agency or do you want to control them? You can't have both.