3 ms·
I always see this parroted. But there is two facts that come into play that are ignored biy this bit of propaganda. 1. It's not just housing but transportation
by Gibbon1 8y ago
I always see this parroted. But there is two facts that come into play that are ignored biy this bit of propaganda.
1. It's not just housing but transportation infrastructure. Of which SF has developed nothing other than the 3rd St light rail and the Central Subway. After that there is _nothing_ in the pipeline. Which means nothing will be built for the next 15-20 years.
2. They are building new multifamily. Cost is about $700-1000 a square foot. Unlike you I had a talk with my insurance agent. Guess what, _rebuilding_ costs between $600-1000 a square foot.
Really the solution is not more housing in SF but to move tech bro jobs elsewhere more affordable. Like Detroit.
- criley2 8y ago"Really the solution is not more housing in SF but to move tech bro jobs elsewhere more affordable. Like Detroit." Funny that you call a realistic, economically sound criticism of NIMBY-ism "propaganda" but then go on to attack the entire problem as "techbros". Wow, talk about intellectual dishonesty. I'm so glad we all learned today that the only problem with SF is "techbros!" That's certainly not "propaganda"! All we have to do fix SF is kick all the techbros out! How convenient for your preferred ideology!
- Gibbon1 8y agoGo ahead please do argue against my points about building costs and transportation infrastructure. I'm waiting.
- chris_mc 8y agoImagine if housing was affordable somewhere other than Stockton. Then maybe people would live in SF and the South Bay (aka: "Silicon Valley") rather than huddling together on the BART and Caltrain. If we had housing closer to our work and commercial areas, people could walk more, too. Instead, folks travel for 1-2 hours each way because they can only afford to live far into the East Bay. I don't know for sure if this would work, but it seems logical that people want to live closer to work, if possible.
- Gibbon1 8y agoThat's why SF has been forcing developers to build multi-family in the core and not Noe Valley Nob Hill, the Sunset, etc. Doesn't fix that cities in the South Bay are allowing developers to tear down single/two story office/commercial and replace it with 4-6 story office buildings and yet they won't rezone for multi-family.
- criley2 8y agoI argued against your ad hominem fallacies quite sufficiently, thank you. Seeing as I found your substantive claims to be backed by no data, evidence or anything other than low-level ad hominem attacks (propaganda, tech bros, etc) I found no reason to engage with such radicalism on the merits. Try speaking like an intelligent person who doesn't fill their "claims" with nasty personal attacks, and you might find the replies to you do the same.
- helen___keller 8y agoBy your own admission wouldn't the answer be more transportation infrastructure to support more dense housing? Nonetheless, I personally "agree" with your solution (in that I work in tech and don't live in SF), but hoping for the free market to do something that it is not doing has never been the solution to a question of public policy. Even if you took the most anti-tech public policy options possible in the city of SF, it wouldn't solve the fact that tech is firmly embedded in the entire metropolitan region which is outside of SF's municipal control. If you really wanted to get "tech bros" out of your city you would need a solution on the level of the California state government, ideally something that intentionally disincentivizes business and venture capital. Good luck on that, in the mean time you're just going to have more "tech bros" moving in and voting for anyone who speaks out in favor of upzoning.
- Gibbon1 8y ago> By your own admission wouldn't the answer be more transportation infrastructure to support more dense housing? Oh sure, SF needs a real subway and another BART tunnel between SOMA and Alameda. BART also has some choke points that need fixing at huge expense. But those projects take about 15-20 years. And currently the Republicans in congress are hostile to those projects. > If you really wanted to get "tech bros" out of your city I don't actually care about tech bro's really. I actually see tech workers in SF being victimized like everyone else. Lot of highly educated bright people paying through the nose to eke out a bare middle class lifestyle. Only because the money and jobs are here not some place more affordable that can more easily take the density increases.
- conanbatt 8y ago> Really the solution is not more housing in SF but to move tech bro jobs elsewhere more affordable. Like Detroit. When the tech bro jobs leave, SF will be in dismay, it wont get better. SF city spends 2,600U$S a month per household. If it were to lose its corporate/sales tax revenues, it would have to cut spending aggressively, and it will not make rent cheaper: it will make it unaffordable, exacerbating unemployment which could lead to rising homeless ness. SF is in a terribly delicate position right now, its just masked by a lot of money.
- FiveSquared 8y agoAnd the homeless wil swarm the now-abaonded hosuing, leading to more debt, whihc leads o people leaving, whihc means new-Detriot!
- davidf18 8y agoPeople want to live in SF, NYC, DC, LA, Boston. They don't want to live in Detroit. Amazon is creating 25,000 jobs each in DC and NYC. Google is doubling its already large presence in NYC to an additional 8,000 or so people. The real issue is simply that of 1) zoning density restrictions that benefit wealthy landlords like President Trump, 2) overuse of historic landmark status, 3) overregulation, 4) firms such as AirBnb which effectively encourages taking apartments off the market for use for Airbnb, and 5) illegal aliens: NYC has an estimated 500,000+ illegal aliens. Democrats claim to hate Trump, but the reality is that Trump is only as wealthy as he is because of Democratic city councils in NYC, SF, DC, Boston, LA who restrict zoning density at the behest of wealthy landlords and their campaign donations. In 2014, NYC only built 20,000 housing units for about 90,000 for all of California, meanwhile in Tokyo alone, 140,000 housing units were built. The reason is that the Japanese federal government has laws against zoning density restrictions which benefit wealthy landlords such as President Trump. The housing shortages in the US is a simple market issue created by politics.
- projectramo 8y agoConfused about what I am supposed to take away from point 2. Rebuilding costs about the same as building. Okay. So? And how do you conclude from 1 and 2 that "Really the solution is not more housing"? I was with you on point 1 (housing and transport go hand in hand. That makes sense). Detroit, along with every other city in the world has been trying to create their own Silicon Valley and ignite a revolution but its just not that easy to do. Just google innovation and government and read a few books worth of text on the various theories of what the problem is. (Not enough VC, not enough tech talent, not enough money, not enough infrastructure etc etc).
- Gibbon1 8y agoThe point is that it's not nimbyism that's primarily driving housing costs here. Because first off rebuilding costs which isn't effected by nimbyism. Because hey this place I'm living in burns down the neighbors can't prevent or slow down rebuilding. And no one's preventing developers from building multifamily in SOMA. And they are. In both cases you can't pencil in affordable housing due to $500-1000 sqft building costs. A point why the city allows developers to building large multifamily SOMA and not in the Sunset is because transportation. The reason I called out the argument as propaganda is because it has everything to do with the axe developers have to grind. And nothing to do with affordable housing. Developers hate having to work the process to get permits because that doesn't add to their bottom line. My response to your point about Detroit and other cities wanting some of the tech bro action is that they aren't getting the love because the river of money is only being pointed towards the cities that the elites want to live in. SF, LA, New York, etc. The solution is to force them to redirect a bunch of that development money to other cities.
- projectramo 8y agoI guess I am unsure of the rules, but I thought the way that the nimbyism mechanism worked to reduce supply is by adding restrictions on density (can't build houses that are very tall) and cost (requiring lots of permits and old houses to look the same and so forth). It seems that nimbyism would increase the cost of building and rebuilding at about the same rate. (I don't see much of a difference between the two in the middle of a big city). So if San Francisco were allowed to build large sky scrapers like NYC, in theory, we would see the housing prices fall. NYC also has housing problems of course. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/05/19/upshot/forty-percent-of-manhattans-buildings-could-not-be-built-today.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/05/19/upshot/forty-...
- hedora 8y agoI’m building a house in the middle of nowhere near SF. Costs for the house itself are trending well under $400/sqft (would be closer to $300 pre- tarrifs; maybe it’ll drop a bit). Once you add in questionable California regulations, the price jumps up to about $$750-800 per square foot. (None of this extra money is in the house itself; it is in the surrounding site.) I think existing homeowners have been voting through “wouldn’t it be nice if everybody else paid for X, even though I would never do that myself” NIMBY regulations which further exasperates the housing shortage. Two concrete examples: In my neighborhood, accessory dwelling units (ADU’s) are capped at 1200 sq ft, but primary homes are capped at 6000 sq ft. There are no colleges nearby, and per TFA, only 50,000 houses under 1400 sq ft were built next year. The ADU is too small to be rented to a family. It is only for au pairs, inlaws and airbnb. The stated purpose of the ADU rule is to increase housing supply. Heh. If this was for adding housing stock, the rule would be “two houses, not to exceed 7200 sq ft”. We are being forced to upgrade our driveway to the point where runoff and landslides may be an issue (the existing driveway is adequate for heavy construction equipment). We will probably need to add retaining walls, and maybe an underground cistern to mitigate the environmental impact of the driveway.
- rsync 8y agoCurious as to where you are building? Marin ?