3 ms·
The Stellar protocol has not been yet peer reviewed. Not saying that is wrong but I would say that when you start relaxing consensus assumptions you can come up
by wslh 8y ago
The Stellar protocol has not been yet peer reviewed. Not saying that is wrong but I would say that when you start relaxing consensus assumptions you can come up with even simpler protocols. For example, using trusted third parties to timestamp your transactions. In this way you solve the ordering issue in consensus (assuming no timestamp can give the same time). For example, imagine if Google, Amazon, Microsoft, and companies from other countries provides this (Microsoft has a timestamp server for creating code certificates).
- akerro 8y ago>For example, imagine if Google, Amazon, Microsoft, and companies from other countries provides this (Microsoft has a timestamp server for creating code certificates). Sooo... paypal on blockchain?
- justtopost 8y agoPlease no. Keep paypal on ebay, and away from the rest of us.
- wslh 8y agoNo, saying that you can rely on third parties just for the timestamp but not for the whole blockchain
- jillesvangurp 8y agoI understand; this has also been a concern for us. However, there's actually very little out there that is actually mature and usable. Bitcoin is not usable for custom applications period. It's nice if you want to trade bitcoin; it doesn't do anything else. Ethereum has enough of a user base that you could argue it is probably OK in terms of security; however as argued it's not really usable in its current form. Everything else is a combination of too young, technically challenged, too small in user base, etc. Bearing this in mind, we picked Stellar based on the fact that it has actually been around for a while and launched late 2017, is used by several more serious players in the ecosystem (e.g. IBM seems to like it) and a few fin tech companies are building stuff with it. It has a few tokens that seem less about speculative trading and more about solving a real problem (e.g. several stable coins that tend to be relatively stable in value, by design). If you look at e.g. EOS, the picture is a bit different. It seems to be favored by asian gambling tokens which have pathetic numbers of transactions per day. Also, they launched after we decided to move to Stellar. Tron seems to have similar issues. Then there are a lot of smaller chains that are currently not launched yet e.g. IOTA, hashgraph, that you might see as potentially of interest in the future. After that comes a long tail of solutions that nobody can vouch for right now. So, we're taking some risks here with Stellar but it seems to be relatively OK for us so far and I haven't really seen anything more suitable for our needs so far. In terms of transactions per second there's way more happening on Stellar than Ethereum is even capable of handling currently. Also, Stellar seem to have distanced themselves a bit from the whole ICO business, which I count as a good thing.