3 ms·
"That is basically profit-making on the back of others' work without their knowledge or consent, and potentially at the expense of the community the poster orig
by nostrademons 16y ago
"That is basically profit-making on the back of others' work without their knowledge or consent, and potentially at the expense of the community the poster originally wished to support."
Doesn't that describe basically all of Web 2.0?
- Silhouette 16y ago> Doesn't that describe basically all of Web 2.0? Not at all. A site that happens to be based on user-generated content is probably using that content with the user's knowledge and consent, just as pg does when HN publishes comments we make here.
- nostrademons 16y agoI was thinking more about sites like FaceBook, where users initially gave their info because the site represented a community they were already part of (like their college), and then FaceBook turned around and sold it to advertisers and app developers.
- Silhouette 16y agoI don't personally use Facebook. I don't like the way they operate, for much the reasons you describe. However, I expect there is at least some small print that users theoretically signed up for when they created an account that gives Facebook the sorts of rights you mentioned, so it's a rather different case. Also, Facebook has been slapped down several times recently by government authorities/privacy regulators for going too far. If I were running an organisation like Facebook or Google, I'd be pretty concerned today about the privacy backlash that seems to be building in many countries as everyday non-geek users become more aware of how these companies operate and the potential risks associated with such liberal use of personal data. I think that's probably a discussion for another thread, though.
- PakG1 16y agoHypothetical musings about the future aside, if it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, and looks like a duck, it's probably a duck? :)