3 ms·
No excuses to Apple. First, 5G is the future, it may not be important at first but it will eventually change. Is a bit of future proofing too much to ask of a
by GuB-42 8y ago
No excuses to Apple.
First, 5G is the future, it may not be important at first but it will eventually change. Is a bit of future proofing too much to ask of a high end smartphone?
Second, 5G is not just about maximum bandwidth, it also gives you access to less saturated frequencies.
The lack of 5G is a very big deal, especially when smartphones vendors struggle to find even minor differentiating factors.
- FPGAhacker 8y agoI agree about future-proofing a phone from the consumer point of view, but it would decrease Apple's margins or increase the price of an already really expensive phone for no current benefit. On the technical side, I think 5G has a serious problem of being blocked by just about anything at those frequencies. I'm sure the RF wizards will get it sorted out, but I imagine early adopters are going to suffer with garbage signal indoors.
- niftich 8y agoMore on this: upcoming 5G implementation proposals, such as 3GPP's '5G NR', have bands [1] in the UHF, SHF, and EHF range, out of which the EHF/mmWave bands are most susceptible to environmental attenuation, but they're also the ones capable of the highest throughput. The UHF bands are rather similar to LTE, and deliver only a modest improvement. So really, 5G is a somewhat abstract standard by ITU-T that specifies requirements, and the industry then delivers a suite of technologies that are deployed together and marketed as 5G. In the case of 4G, the same was true at first, but then non-confirming LTE was cobbled together as a series of progressive enhancements of existing tech by the industry, and marketed as "4G", co-opting the term in consumers' minds and making the prior formal definition irrelevant. With the hype and anticipation over 5G rapidly intensifying, there's a chance the same might happen again, as networks are eager to brand any progressive enhancement as a true differentiating factor. It's enabled by the term "5G" having cachet with consumers, yet its technical specs are relatively obscure so average customers lack meaningful information and recourse to challenge the marketing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5G_NR_frequency_bands https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5G_NR_frequency_bands
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoThe first LTE phones were battery hogs. That's not what I would call future proof. Let's wait and see what 5G will do before we start throwing rocks. I, personally, don't mind Apple waiting a year or so before introducing a 5G phone. Besides, most of the people I know who talk about future proof phones, tend to be the same people who upgrade every year or two.