3 ms·
You can’t escape UI work in math, either. The comprehensibility of the notation system is crucial to forward progress. Which makes it unfortunate that a lot of
by jacobolus 16y ago
You can’t escape UI work in math, either. The comprehensibility of the notation system is crucial to forward progress. Which makes it unfortunate that a lot of mathematical notation ends up being unnecessarily arcane, taking ideas that make perfectly clear sense graphically or intuitively and mangling them into an impenetrable tangle. And I don’t think there are enough serious challenges to bad notation: if a notation has worked for a few people trying to prove things, others too often accept it and move on.
Some of the complexity may be necessary in the name of precision, but a lot of the time it’s simply a design failure. Part of the problem may be that it doesn’t seem like mathematicians get any real training in notation design or abstraction communication. Theorem proving exercises in school almost always stress rigor over clarity of explanation: proofs in homework are always either correct or not correct, and what is tested by them is students’ comprehension of existing notation and previously developed abstractions, but there is no exercise which tests students ability to invent good new abstractions or notations.