3 ms·
You also have to provide the immigrants with whatever social spending to which locals are entitled. They cost money; if the immigrants pay less in taxes than th
by nine_k 8y ago
You also have to provide the immigrants with whatever social spending to which locals are entitled. They cost money; if the immigrants pay less in taxes than they receive in social benefits, they are a net economic loss. And, as you may expect, a poor immigrant likely pays little or even no taxes if their income is low enough.
Also, lowering the price of labor in a particular industry makes other people in it be paid less, or fired. As a result, they buy less, etc, slowing down the entire economy, influencing maybe your own wages.
- cabalamat 8y ago> You also have to provide the immigrants with whatever social spending to which locals are entitled Quite a lot of countries don't.
- vkou 8y ago> You also have to provide the immigrants with whatever social spending to which locals are entitled Do you? Why? I'm not saying you shouldn't, but I am saying this is an assumption worth questioning. Also, consider that adult immigrants save your social services one of the biggest costs borne by our society - a K-12 education. Someone with a high school diploma arriving to the US is a flat-out gift of ~$140,000 worth of education.
- jlangenauer 8y ago> You also have to provide the immigrants with whatever social spending to which locals are entitled. Absolutely not true. The UK, for instance, explicitly states on its work visas "No recourse to public funds", although they are happy for immigrants to pay the same taxes as locals...