3 ms·
> Who will benefit from the DOE sinking a billion tax dollars into building graphene fabs? Isn't that the answer that {your_country} should own these industrie
by r00fus 8y ago
> Who will benefit from the DOE sinking a billion tax dollars into building graphene fabs?
Isn't that the answer that {your_country} should own these industries before China/Russia/etc does?
Because you can bet China is investing. I know someone who used to be the general manager of a large Chinese manufacturing plant, and all he wanted to talk about was how graphene was/is/will change whatever industry/tech I discussed.
From a US perspective, there's billions wasted on make-work programs (TSA) and corporate handouts and subsidies that would greatly increase the tax base and develop local markets by reinvesting instead into new tech.
- vkou 8y agoWhat does it matter to me that Boeing is an American firm, owned by a bunch of international institutional investors, as opposed to a Korean one, owned by a bunch of international institutional investors? Is it because there used to be a Boeing factory in my town, before they moved all the jobs to somewhere cheaper? To put it another way - why should I care that a few private companies in {my_country} own these industries? Their owners aren't paying me dividends, I'm not going to pay for their R&D. If you want to sink this money into building a state-owned industry, where the profits are distributed between the people, sure, that's another story, we can talk about that. If not, appealing to nationalism is a poor motivator for me to fund your cottage industry. If you want my money, make me a shareholder. > From a US perspective, there's billions wasted on make-work programs (TSA) and corporate handouts and subsidies that would greatly increase the tax base and develop local markets by reinvesting instead into new tech. So, the solution is corporate handouts for industries that you like? Handouts for people growing corn, or groping your junk when you cross borders are bad, but handouts for people making graphene are good? (Unlike corn, the jury's still out on whether or not it will actually be useful. Maybe it's the next plastic. Maybe it's the next beanie baby. Maybe it's the next asbestos. It's too early to tell, and "Let's manufacture tonnes of it, before anyone has any use for it" is a solution in search of a problem.) I mean, sure, our current allocation of spending is probably not optimal[1]. I do think, that the onus is on you to demonstrate that sinking a billion dollars into building a graphene fab is better then sinking a billion dollars into killing fossil fuels, or shrinking classroom sizes, or providing free early-age child-care, or free flu shots[2], or any one of a dozen other things we should be doing[3]. [1] To be fair, I am 100% certain it is not optimal. [2] http://info.totalwellnesshealth.com/blog/bid/190040/How-to-Measure-the-Value-of-On-Site-Flu-Shots http://info.totalwellnesshealth.com/blog/bid/190040/How-to-M... - The ROI of a flu shot is >200%. [3] Not to mention that a lot of the time, being the first mover in an industry is unnecessary. Let someone else figure out if something is worth doing. If its that important, a sovereign state can always catch up, and develop a local industry, through incentives and tariffs - once the field is proven.