3 ms·
I don't think we have a shortage of ideas for accomplishing this. What we have is a shortage of willpower. All it takes is one asshole being put into a rehabil
by vkou 8y ago
I don't think we have a shortage of ideas for accomplishing this. What we have is a shortage of willpower.
All it takes is one asshole being put into a rehabilitation program[1], or one sufficiently high-profile crime committed by someone in a program/on parole, for half the country to sour about prison reform.
It's easier to send the bad people to the gulag, and forget about them. Treating crime in a constructive way is expensive, and doesn't work 100% of the time, so why bother?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Tori_Stafford#Aftermath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Tori_Stafford#Afterm...
- briandear 8y agoPeople that kill people or commit violent, life-changing assaults such as rape ought not be rehabilitated, but permanently caged. Nobody accidentally rapes and kills a child. There isn't an argument that a killer/rapist was doing it because they were in poverty and needed money -- instead it's just pure evil. Those types of people should be sent away forever. For non-violent crimes, especially victimless crimes like drug possession, reforms are definitely warranted, but anyone advocating on behalf of convicted, violent criminals gets no respect from me. To get most of the country on board with prison reform, it's not particularly hard: simply exclude anyone who has committed a violent crime from being a part of those reforms. I don't think there are too many rational people out there that want someone to get locked up for 25 years for possessing marijuana or stealing a car.
- vkou 8y agoSo, prison reform starts with life sentences, without parole, for all violent offenders? For juvenile offenders, too? (The United States is, afaik, the only country in the world that imposes this punishment on juveniles - of which ~2,500 are currently serving it) That's certainly a consistent approach, but not a particularly popular one the world over. If the only thing you're doing is trying to minimize harm to non-convicts, that's one way to go about it, though. According to the stats for recidivism among persons convicted of homicide, though, you may be over-optimizing. [1] Or not. [2] [1] http://www.newjersey.gov/corrections/pdf/REU/Recidivism_Among_Homicide_Offenders.pdf http://www.newjersey.gov/corrections/pdf/REU/Recidivism_Amon... - In conclusion, none of the 336 homicide offenders committed another murder. However, we found that the highest risk of recidivism for new violent or drug crimes were the felony homicide group (slightly over one-third), followed by the altercation precipitated homicide offenders (27%), which was in sharp contrast to the domestic violence homicide offenders with less than 10% recidivism due to a new violent or drug offense, and the accidental homicides with 17% recidivism due to a new violent or drug offense. [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8689372 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8689372 - A similar study in Finland had a higher recidivism rate for homicide - where people released after serving ~5 years of a homicide sentence were ~14 times more likely then the general population to commit another homicide. The difference could be explained by shorter sentencing. Someone convicted of a homicide at 21, released at 26, is far more likely to be a recidivist then someone convicted at 21, and released at 52.
- briandear 8y agoMurderers should be in prison for as long as their victims are dead. If you intentionally kill someone, you clearly don't belong in society ever again.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sifoobar 8y agoHave you considered the fact that practically everyone who commits these kinds of crimes had similar things done to them; often as children, often by relatives? Everyone is responsible for their actions. And some people have a long way to go to before they've healed their traumas. But pretending that some are evil and others are not isn't solving the problem. It would be more constructive to ask what can be done to prevent people from becoming this messed up, children from being treated so horribly etc. And how to best help people heal and take back control over their lives.
- briandear 8y ago> Have you considered the fact that practically everyone who commits these kinds of crimes had similar things done to them No excuse. Defending child-killers because they themselves were (potentially) abused as children? That's nonsense. They still killed someone; their past traumas don't give them a free pass to inflict horror and pain on others. The past traumas of the killers doesn't matter to the child they murdered. If you have a past trauma -- go see a doctor. It was in Canada, medical and psychiatric care is supposed to be free right? That they didn't avail themselves to that resource and instead chose to rape and kill a little girl -- that's on them. Rationalizing the actions of child-killers is disgusting.
- function_seven 8y agoYou're not being charitable with your interpretation of parent's comment. You quoted the first line, then ignored this: > Everyone is responsible for their actions. And some people have a long way to go to before they've healed their traumas. But pretending that some are evil and others are not isn't solving the problem. It's not a rationalization of child-killing. It's a partial explanation as to why some people do that. There's no value judgement being made, just a clinical evaluation of causes and effects. People who commit terrible crimes are responsible for their actions. But it's far too convenient to just label them as evil and move on. Something made them evil. Something wired their brain that way. We are not the authors of our own personalities. Don't misunderstand me. I'm not claiming that all people are redeemable. Some aren't. There are cases where the only rational (and ethical!) thing to do is separate the perpetrator from the rest of civil society, for our own protection. But we do ourselves a big favor if we allow ourselves to question and study the origin of these behaviors. And if we allow ourselves to advance the study of rehabilitation and reform. Just as it is morally correct to protect the society at-large from predators, it is also, I think, a moral requirement to find better ways at fixing broken people. Just like we do with cancer, AIDS, or any other ailment. Expand that to include mental disorders. The brain is another organ. Right now we suck at verifiably correcting for psychological disorders. (Hell, we can't even agree on what constitutes one). Because we're bad at it, we take the safe approach of caging dangerous people. That's fine. It's the best we can do with our current state of knowledge. But we should strive to learn more, so that we can make more accurate decisions on who should remain caged and who is eligible for reform.
- hervature 8y agoAs someone who has taught voluntarily in prisons, I agree fully that non-violent crimes (especially marijuana related offenses) benefit from educational programs with regards to recidivism rates. I used to be of the mind that violent criminals were beyond "saving" but that mentality began to wane the more I taught in the prison system. This was partly due to the fact that I never looked into my students' histories so that I couldn't be biased by my predilections on the severity of their crimes. By being blind to their crimes, it made me reevaluate my stance as some of my students probably had committed violent crimes but they were all great students. Now, my moral stance is that everyone deserves access to an education, no matter the circumstances. If one starts to restrict access due to severity of crimes committed, then we get ourselves into using education as a reward/punishment which should make everyone's ethical spidey senses stand on edge. Notice that this doesn't get into the nuanced discussion about the types of education or accommodations required for individuals who are considered dangerous to other students. Finally, for those who think murderers cannot change, I suggest watching the Mexico episode of "Inside the Real Narcos" on Netflix where they interview a Mexican Cartel hitman who truly seems regretful of his crimes.