5 ms·
Chicago’s Deep Tunnel: The solution to urban flooding, or a cautionary tale?
- hinkley 8y agoIt seems to be taken as a given that it’s too late to segregate the storm water system from the sewers.
- cbkeller 8y agoYeah, I never noticed them mention that possibility, even to dismiss it.
- cozzyd 8y agoPresumably that requires work everywhere in the city instead of at a few key points like this project which makes it harder, even if more effective.
- fourthark 8y agoThis article takes a really really long time to get to the point. It raves and raves about how great the system is and then the final page it says oh BTW it doesn't work, too much flow, should have diverted that rainwater.
- ams6110 8y agoSolving the flooding wasn't really the point. It's Chicago. The point was a multi billion dollar project and all the graft, bribery, and political favors that come with it.
- code_duck 8y agoThat makes me think of another large construction project that is currently under discussion nationally.
- snowwindwaves 8y agoDoing nothing, Sewers backing up and death by cholera is preferable?
- hermitdev 8y agoWhat's to say all of those are mutually exclusive? Chicago can want nice things and still have bribery, graft, political favors and nepotism (you missed that one).
- hermitdev 8y agoI think it basically is a given. To segregate storm water from sewer would require a rebuild of the system. Pretty impractical at this point. It can be done in some cases. I live in the west suburbs of Chicago, and the storm water from my (less than 5 year old) complex drains into the Salt Creek. I don't think my city is connected to the big dig, but we do have the capability to dump into a local quarry. The quarry has also been used to dump snow into for large winter storms. We've also been through a large expansion in recent years of green areas and detention drainage areas to alleviate flooding. Living right on the Salt Creek, I routinely see the water level fluctuate by around 10 feet or so after even a decent storm. We're probably about 5-6 feet above normal right now after recent storms.
- Retric 8y agoYou don’t need to fix this in a weekend. Chicago is likely to be around in 300 years. So, solve 3% of the problem every decade and it gets fixed. Meanwhile runoff becomes a 3% smaller problem every decade.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ryanmarsh 8y agoGrand Rapids is proof you can do it faster than 3% per decade.
- jessriedel 8y agoI agree it's useful evidence, but Grand Rapids is an order of magnitude smaller than Chicago. Geology could be very different too for all I know. Being able to do it in one place does not necessarily make it feasible in the other.
- danjayh 8y agoGrand Rapids did it (and Lansing is doing it) in Michigan. Yes, a smaller scale, but still a big enough scale to show that it can be done. In GR, it fixed the problem, period.
- TYPE_FASTER 8y agoBoston and surrounding areas have been working on that for years, with good results. Here's some info if you're interested: http://www.mwra.state.ma.us/03sewer/html/sewcso.htm#16southdorchesterbay http://www.mwra.state.ma.us/03sewer/html/sewcso.htm#16southd... The specific project I linked to involved installing over 25 miles of storm drain to avoid combined sewer/storm overflows into the ocean. We lived on one of the impacted streets. Older houses had gutter downspouts that dumped all rainwater into the combined storm drain/sewer system. The MWRA came to neighborhood association meetings, and helped residents to re-aim downspouts onto green space.
- vermontdevil 8y agoIndy is undergoing a similar project - DigIndy - but it’ll be separate from the sewer system. I think it’s halfway through now. https://www.citizensenergygroup.com/Our-Company/Our-Projects/Dig-Indy https://www.citizensenergygroup.com/Our-Company/Our-Projects...
- toomuchtodo 8y agoWow, I had no idea this was in progress. Thanks for sharing!
- chiefalchemist 8y agoIronic. The project makes Chicago more livable, which increases development / population which...is not sustainable. Cities close to water used to be a necessity. Now such locations are a liability. It's difficult to imagine politicians and local leaders coming clean on such things. Side note: I wonder if Amazon factored such things into its decision(s) for picking its new HQ city(s).
- AckSyn 8y agoIt's as sustainable if the infrastructure can support it, which they seem to be doing fine. Honestly, this doom and gloom with the overpopulation pseudoscience is getting old just like the anti vaxxers.
- pochamago 8y agoI don't think a growing population is Chicago's biggest worry right now https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/breaking/ct-met-chicago-cook-county-population-20180320-story,amp.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/breaking/ct-met-ch...
- tacomonstrous 8y agoThat trend will reverse in a decade or so. The losses are entirely because of a fed-up Black population deciding to migrate to the sunbelt instead of continuing to tolerate de facto segregation. Here's a great Twitter thread about this phenomenon: https://twitter.com/petesaunders3/status/1080508428093673474?s=20 https://twitter.com/petesaunders3/status/1080508428093673474...
- RobLach 8y agoMaking cities more livable is not sustainable? I don’t even know what this means. Cities are the most efficient way of sustaining populations. Making them better at that is only a net good.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoRead the article. Aside from the arc of the idea, be sure to note that Chicago is built in a swamp; and that more and more rain is more than the tunnel system can bear. Your statement might be true. However, it's not so much so for Chicago (which is obvious when reading the article).
- danjayh 8y agoThe crazy thing about this article is that it presents Chicago's solution (make the combined sewer bigger), then solutions that are being tried in other cities (increase permeability), and then completely ignores the entirely successful solution that's been used by Grand Rapids (and soon Lansing) on the other side of the lake: Separate the storm and wastewater sewers. Grand Rapids used to regularly have sewer overflows into the local river (not flooding, though - there was enough capacity to actually get the crap and water into the river). Over the last few decades, a separate storm sewer has been built, and this water can be treated more quickly. The storm sewer skims off things like oil, etc. and then returns the rainwater to the river and lake. No impact on the shit sewer. No shit and piss in the river, no shit and piss in the lake. It works, and it's what should be done in other cities that have this problem (and maybe a little bit of permeability on the side).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- LoneWolf123 8y agoIn Chicago, storm sewers would definitely contain human waste.
- bigpicture 8y ago> The crazy thing about this article is that it presents Chicago's solution (make the combined sewer bigger) Except that Chicago's publicly stated position is that the Deep Tunnel system is not the solution. This is not a new thing, either. It's been that way for more than 2 decades. For more than 10 years, they've had a stormwater management building ordinance and (with few exceptions) any project (new construction or renovation) that changes the amount of stormwater exiting a piece of property is subject to it. It limits the flow rate of stormwater leaving, the volume of stormwater leaving, and the amount of sediment that can leave a piece of property. It is entirely math-based, with published formulas and coefficients and makes determining compliance straightforward, objective and fast. They've received international recognition for their incremental approach to stormwater management, which recognizes that the vast majority of property in the city is private property built long ago. As for public property, whenever the city rebuilds an alleyway, it is done with permeable pavement and is disconnected from the sewer. Whenever the city rebuilds a road, it is disconnected from the sewer to the extent that surrounding private property allows. Last year an entire block of a road near me was rebuilt and the side that was adjacent to a railroad embankment was built with swales every 50 feet or so to manage stormwater. It was actually visually attractive as well.
- mnw21cam 8y agohttps://outline.com/URJEBs https://outline.com/URJEBs - because of obnoxious illegal click-past "I agree" page.
- stevep001 8y agoMinneapolis and St Paul separated their sewers. Took 55 years and $330 million investment. http://www.minneapolismn.gov/publicworks/stormwater/cso/cso_history http://www.minneapolismn.gov/publicworks/stormwater/cso/cso_... https://metrocouncil.org/News-Events/Wastewater-Water/Newsletters/Sewer-separation,-inflow-and-infiltration-reductio.aspx https://metrocouncil.org/News-Events/Wastewater-Water/Newsle...