6 ms·
For those complaining about slow progress of the GIMP (I'm guilty as well) remember it's a part time project where most of the work is done by 3 people (from re
by phkahler 8y ago
For those complaining about slow progress of the GIMP (I'm guilty as well) remember it's a part time project where most of the work is done by 3 people (from reading this post). One thing about "free" is that everybody wants it and almost nobody actually wants to DO it. I wonder how many projects that take donations actually do reasonably in terms of paying developers - I doubt it's very many.
- fundamental 8y agoUser facing open source software projects do take a lot of time to make new progress or even just refine what's there. When the primary audience is non-technical users, that provides a lot of surface area for people to complain without a comparatively large set of users who would likely transition from using to contributing. From watching things over the years in the open source audio domain I agree that donations/other-funding-mechanisms are really hard to get right in this space.
- sneakernets 8y agoYou also have to account for the amount of work it once took, and the mindset that creates. It's another domain entirely as a result. The fact that Audacity or GIMP exists at all and was free was shocking to a lot of us. Programming audiovisual stuff competently took knowing the CPU on a machine-code level if you wanted to get a usable program (and wanted clients to be able to get something done in weeks, not months) and the idea of doing all that work for free would just get belly laughs from most folks. There's a reason the highly optimized stuff still costs hard money, and it's not due to hubris.
- slondr 8y agoYep. There's a reason that the GIMP project also spawned one of the most widely-used graphical abstraction layers in desktop computing history.
- blattimwind 8y agoUnless you count all Windows frameworks as just Windows that seems like a stretch. Also the reason is "A small company misjudged how to-the-letter-of-the-law GPL developers were", perhaps with a sprinkle of "some people rather maim C than using anything else".
- pantalaimon 8y agoI think what GP referes to is that Gimp started the GimpToolKit, otherwise known as GTK which is the foundation of Gnome.
- blattimwind 8y agoYes and I'm referring to Win32, WinForms, WPF, UWP/WinUI, Cocoa and Qt are very likely more widely deployed. Though even the last place of the commonly used frameworks is still relatively widely used.
- reichardt 8y agoI'm unsure how blender is organized but they seem to compete with the proprietary competition on a much higher level. Does blender have so many more developers working on it than Gimp? Edit: Seems like blender is indeed better funded: https://fund.blender.org/ https://fund.blender.org/ Nothing crazy tough.
- Jach 8y agoAt some point in the last 5-8 years Blender went from being "the gimp of 3D" no one seemed to really want to use (like Gimp) given the alternatives to actually being a competitor. I'm not sure what happened but it's on the list of things to discuss if I ever sit down with an industry veteran in the modeling space...
- slondr 8y agoWhat happened is Blender followed a linear development trajectory, constantly adding new features and fixing bugs at a reasonable pace. GIMP, on the other hand, adds a handful of features once every year and a half. Marketing was also a factor. Years ago, Blender was similar to how OpenShot is now --- pretty much unknown to the general public, but it shows up in blog posts a lot, and those who use it think it has potential. As time went on and it became more featureful, the news about Blender changed from "This promising project is working on making a modeling suite..." to "This software can replace 3DS Max right now and it's completely free". GIMP's publicity has only gotten worse over the years as it suffers from perceived bit rot and an inability to add requested features over the course of a decade.
- kakarot 8y agoWhat happened was the interface was insanely improved from the unnavigable mess of the early 2000's, sculpting was added, and a host of other features brought Blender to parity with its non-free brethren.
- dylan-m 8y agoOne thing which helps Blender is that its target audience is better equipped to write code, or at least think about code enough to connect with the "project" side of open source software. That doesn't mean Blender users need to do that to be productive, but it definitely gives actual users a stronger voice. I find free software generally doesn't work as well when there's a hard split between the developers and the users, unless those developers are incredibly empathetic, clever, and well funded. (Or just fully aware of the problem they're solving, but it's hard to find a large sample of people that can write a really good vector graphic editor, have a clue about UI design, and are also keenly aware of the problems people deal with when they're drawing a graphic novel). You can see that process working well with Blender's open movie projects (https://www.blender.org/about/projects/ https://www.blender.org/about/projects/). I haven't paid attention to them recently, but in the past they have been structured around building some new feature in Blender, such as improving the video editor and motion tracking experience (Tears of Steel), or rendering and sculpting (Sintel).
- krapp 8y agoGimp is an interesting case study in the assumptions behind free software and the free market. One would assume that the desired features would have simply been offered as pull requests by the community, or, barring their acceptance, multiple competing forks would emerge filling the market need going unmet by the Gimp developers. Yet somehow there seems to be just as much 'vendor lock in' with FOSS as there is with proprietary software.
- vanderZwan 8y agoI suspect the 'vendor lock in' here comes from the up-front investment to catch up with the existing solution.
- kgwxd 8y agoIt's some kind of lock-in but it's not "vendor lock-in".
- jononor 8y agoI think 'barriers to entry' or might be a better term. Some barriers are quite natural/inherent (hard to pay devs in open-source), while others might have technical solutions (it used to be hard to package&deliver cross-platform desktop apps).
- jononor 8y agoThere has been plenty of forks of GIMP, but none really picked up steam. It has been forked over the name, over the UI not being close enough to Photoshop and over core features like high-bitdepth support. In a FOSS project fork, one needs to out-code the original project in terms of features delivered to users, out-market it to build brand recognition, and create enough network effects that potential contributors choose the fork instead of the original. And with the stamina to do this for a few years while shake out. Since there seldom is a lot of money to go around for funding this effort, it is very challenging. OpenOffice -> LibreOffice was a relatively recent successful example, but it took many people a lot of work over many years. Node.js -> IO.JS -> Node.js was interesting in that they merged back together, with the combined momentum of the fork and original.
- MegaDeKay 8y agoIndeed, probably not many. But one of those that seems like it is doing quite well and is in a similar space is Krita. They have a healthy number of contributors, fund developers, and are making good progress quickly on a powerful application that works very well and has a lot of polish. https://krita.org/en/ https://krita.org/en/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xvilka 8y agoThey could have run Kickstarter campaign like Krita did. Surely it would allow to hire more people in the team. But seems they don't want that for some unknown reason.
- prokoudine 8y agoThe 'unknown' reason is very well known and public for a long time: https://www.gimp.org/docs/userfaq.html#arent-you-interested-in-doing-paid-development-of-gimp-via-crowdfunding https://www.gimp.org/docs/userfaq.html#arent-you-interested-...
- xvilka 8y agoYou can make a campaign to hire full-time developers from the outside then. It is just less money available for personal donations rather using collective campaign for one organization. See Krita as an example.
- prokoudine 8y ago> You can make a campaign to hire full-time developers from the outside then. No, we can't. Managing a campaign and its outcome is a full-time job. Should we first campaign to fund the campaign management? But then we need to campaign to campaign to manage campaign. And so on.